The Other Greta Effect (OGE)
Recognizing Youth Climate Activists Beyond Thunberg
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7146/kkf.v37i1.141088Nøgleord:
youth climate activism, media studies, climate justice, decolonial studiesResumé
Since Greta Thunberg’s rise to international prominence as a youth climate activist, other youth activists have been identified in mass media as the ‘Greta Thunberg’ of their respective nations or regions. Through an analysis informed by decolonial approaches to global media studies and climate change and scholarship on climate justice, this article finds that this discursive phenomenon, termed the ‘Other Great Effect’ (OGE), constructs Greta Thunberg as a global icon whose identity and approach establish a normative framework for youth climate activism. The OGE supports a universalizing narrative that legitimates the global North as leaders on climate change policy and downplays the different contexts, experiences, and identities represented within youth activism. Through case studies of four young activists who have been subjected to the Other Greta Effect, we find that the OGE paradoxically contributes to these activists’ illegibility while also providing opportunities to call for a more diverse climate movement. Finally, we present the Global Youth Activists Map as an alternative visualization that advances a more intersectional approach to climate justice.
Referencer
Bainbridge, A. and Vimonsuk, S. 2019. Meet Thailand’s answer to Greta Thunberg. She’s only 12, but her passion is already paying off. Australian Broadcasting Corporation. [Online]. 31 December. [Accessed June 17, 2024]. Available from: https://www.abc.net.au/news/2020-01-01/meet-thailands-answer-to- greta-thunberg/11817228.
Banet-Weiser, S. 2018. Empowered: Popular feminism and popular misogyny. Durham, North Carolina: Duke University Press Books.
Bastida, X. 2020. My Name Is Not Greta Thunberg: Why Diverse Voices Matter in the Climate Movement. The Elders. [Online]. June 19. [Accessed June 15, 2022]. Available from: https://theelders.org/news/ my-name-not-greta-thunberg-why-diverse-voices-matter-climate-movement.
Bengal, R. 2019. The Seas Are Rising—and So Are They. Vogue. [Online]. October 4. [Accessed June 23, 2022]. Available from: https://www.vogue.com/article/youth-climate-change-activists-climate- week-2019.
Bergmann, Z., and Ossewaarde, R. 2020. Youth Climate Activists Meet Environmental Governance: Ageist Depictions of the FFF Movement and Greta Thunberg in German Newspaper Coverage. Journal of Multicultural Discourses. 15(3), 267–90. doi:10.1080/17447143.2020.1745211
Campbell, M. 2020. Anuna de Wever on Fighting Climate Change and ‘Incapable’ Politicians. Euronews. [Online]. October 19. [Accessed August 4, 2022]. Available from: https://www.euronews.com/ green/2020/10/19/anuna-de-wever-on-fighting-climate-change-and-incapable-politicians.
Chan, E. 2021. Activist Vanessa Nakate on Amplifying The Voices Of Those On The Frontlines Of Climate Change. Vogue. [Online]. October 29. [Accessed June 23, 2022]. Available from: https://www.vogue. com/article/vanessa-nakate-activist-book-bringing-new-african-voice-to-climate-crisis.
Chatterton, P., Featherstone, D., and Routledge, P. 2013. Articulating Climate Justice in Copenhagen: Antagonism, the Commons, and Solidarity. Antipode 45, 602–620. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467- 8330.2012.01025.x
Chowdhury, E. 2009. Locating Global Feminisms Elsewhere: Braiding US Women of Color and Transnational Feminisms. Cultural Dynamics. 21(2), 51–78. doi:10.1177/0921374008100407
Conrad, R. 2021. Youth Climate Activists Trading on Time: Temporal Strategies in Xiuhtezcatl Martinez’s We Rise and Greta Thunberg’s No One Is Too Small to Make a Difference. The Lion and the Unicorn 45, 226–243. doi:10.1353/uni.2021.0017
Coughlin, C., and Hauck, C. 2023. What Kind of Hero is Greta? The Promise and Problem of Youth Climate Activism in Swedish Opinion Journalism. In: Etherington, M. ed. Environmental Education: An Interdisciplinary Approach to Nature. Eugene, OR: Wipf & Stock Publishers, 155–68.
Goddard, A. 2022. Every Day Eco-Heroes - Autumn Peltier. Alternatives Journal. [Online]. April 8. [Accessed August 4, 2022]. Available from: https://www.alternativesjournal.ca/community/every-day- eco-heroes-autumn-peltier/.
Ghosh, B. 2011. Global icons: Apertures to the Popular. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Morera Quesada, A. P. 2022. Global Youth Activists Map. Responses to Greta Thunberg in International Media. https://pages.stolaf.edu/responses-to-thunberg/for-students/global-youth-activists/
Han, H., and Ahn, S. W. 2020. Youth Mobilization to Stop Global Climate Change: Narratives and Impact. Sustainability. 12(10), 4127. doi:4127.10.3167/ghs.2020.130202
Hanson, H. 2019. Autumn Peltier is Canada’s Own Greta Thunberg. Narcity. [Online]. September 26. [Accessed August 4, 2022]. Available from: https://www.narcity.com/autumn-peltier-is-canadas-own-greta-thunberg.
Haugseth, J. F., and Smeplass, E. 2022. The Greta Thunberg Effect: A Study of Norwegian Youth’s
Reflexivity on Climate Change. Sociology. 57(4), 921–39. doi:10.1177/00380385221122416 Hennig, R., Jonasson, A.-K. and Degerman, P. 2018. Introduction. In: Hennig, R., Jonasson, A.-K. and
Degerman, P., eds. Nordic Narratives of Nature and the Environment. Lanham: Lexington Books, 1–18. Hernández, B. 2019. Licypriya Kangujam y Vanessa Nakate, las ‘Gretas’ del sur. El País. [Online]. December 6. [Accessed June 24, 2022]. Available from: https://elpais.com/sociedad/2019/12/06/actualidad/1575651733_426685.html.
Hesford, W. S. 2011. Spectacular Rhetorics: Human Rights Visions, Recognitions, Feminisms. Durham, NC: Duke University Press.
Hess, L. 2020. Meet the 19-Year-Old Belgian Activist Taking a Global Outlook on the Climate Crisis. Vogue. [Online]. November 14. [Accessed June 23, 2022]. Available from: https://www.vogue.com/article/anuna-de-wever-profile-greta-thunberg-documentary.
Jung, J., Petkanic, P., Nan, D., and Kim, J.H.. 2020. When a Girl Awakened the World: A User and Social
Message Analysis of Greta Thunberg. Sustainability. 12(7), 2707. doi:10.3390/su12072707 Lakind, A. 2020. Remixing Environmental Icons for a Better Future. Edge Effects. [Online]. April 14. [Accessed June 23, 2022]. Available from: https://edgeeffects.net/remixing-environmental-icons-for-a-
better-future/.
Locke, J. 2023. Beyond Heroes and Hostility: Greta Thunberg, Vanessa Nakate, and the Transnational
Politics of Girl Power. NORA : Nordic Journal of Women’s Studies. 31(2), 117–27. doi:10.1080/08038740.2023.2206673.
Lundström, C, and Teitelbaum, B. R. 2017. Nordic Whiteness: An Introduction. Scandinavian Studies. 89(2), 151–58.
Madhanagopal, D., Beer, C.T., Nikku, B.R. and Pelser, A.J. eds. 2022. Environment, climate, and social justice: perspectives and practices from the Global South. Singapore: Springer Nature Singapore.
Marquardt, J., Lövbrand, E. and Buhre, F. 2024. The Politics of Youth Representation at Climate Change Conferences: Who Speaks, Who Is Spoken of, and Who Listens? Global Environmental Politics. 24(2), 19–45. doi:10.1162/glep_a_00736.
Martínez García, A. B. 2020. Constructing an Activist Self: Greta Thunberg’s Climate Activism as Life Writing. Prose Studies. (41)3, 349–66, doi:10.1080/01440357.2020.1808923.
McFadden, C. 2020. Vanessa Nakate and Perceptions of Black Student Activists. The Journal of Sustainability Education 24, ISSN: 2151-7452.
Midttun, A. and Olsson, L. 2018. Eco-Modernity Nordic Style: The Challenge of Aligning Ecological and Socio-Economic Sustainability. In: Witoszek, N. and Midttun, A., eds. Sustainable Modernity. United Kingdom: Routledge, 204–28. doi:10.4324/9781315195964-11.
Mies, M. and Shiva, V. 2014. Ecofeminism. London & New York: Zed Books.
Molder, A. L., Lakind, A., Clemmons, Z. E., and Chen, K., 2022. Framing the Global Youth Climate Movement: A Qualitative Content Analysis of Greta Thunberg’s Moral, Hopeful, and Motivational Framing on Instagram. The International Journal of Press/Politics 27, 668–695. https://doi.org/10.1177/19401612211055691
Moriarty, S. 2021. Modeling Environmental Heroes in Literature for Children: Stories of Youth Climate Activist Greta Thunberg. The Lion and the Unicorn. (45)2, 192–210. doi:10.1353/uni.2021.0015. Nakate, V. 2021. A Bigger Picture: My Fight to Bring a New African Voice to the Climate Crisis. Boston: Mariner Books.
Nisbett, N. and Spaiser, V. 2023. Moral Power of Youth Activists – Transforming international climate Politics? Global Environmental Change. 82, 102717. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2023.102717
Passmore, M. 2023. “Greta of Sport” Wants (Green) Gold at Olympics - It Wasn’t Easy to Take a Stand, the Schoolgirl Athlete Who Won’t Fly to World Championships Tells Charlotte Lytton. The Times, January 28, 15.
Prakoso, S. G., Timorria, I. F., and Murtyantoro, A. P. 2021. Social Media Interconnection between People: Greta Thunberg’s Influence on the Climate Movement. IOP Conference Series. Earth and Environmental Science. 905(1), 012136. doi:10.1088/1755-1315/905/1/012136
Responses to Greta Thunberg in International Media. 2019. https://pages.stolaf.edu/responses-to-thunberg/.
Ryalls, E. D., and Mazzarella, S. R. 2021. “Famous, Beloved, Reviled, Respected, Feared, Celebrated”: Media Construction of Greta Thunberg. Communication, Culture and Critique. 14(3): 438–53.doi:10.1093/ccc/tcab006.
Sabherwal, A., et al. 2021. The Greta Thunberg Effect: Familiarity with Greta Thunberg Predicts Intentions to Engage in Climate Activism in the United States. Journal of Applied Social Psychology. (51)4, 321–33. doi:10.1111/jasp.12737
Salerno, F. 2023. The Greta Thunberg Effect on Climate Equity: A Worldwide Google Trend Analysis. Sustainability. 15(7), 6233. doi:6233.10.3390/su15076233
Sánchez, A. 2019. La adolescente que levanta a los institutos belgas contra el cambio climático. El País. [Online]. April 22. [Accessed June 17, 2024]. Available from: https://elpais.com/sociedad/2019/02/14/actualidad/1550157146_796456.html#
Segran, E. 2019. If Greta Thunberg inspires you, you’ll love these 4 teen climate activists too. Fast Company. [Online]. September 25. [Accessed June 17, 2024]. Available from: https://www. fastcompany.com/90409156/if-greta-thunberg-inspires-you-youll-love-these-5-teen-climate-activists- too
Spaiser, V., Nisbett, N. and Stefan, C.G. 2022. “How dare you?”—The normative challenge posed by Fridays for Future. PLOS Climate 1(10), e0000053. doi: 10.1371/journal.pclm.0000053.
Staff. 2021. La mexicana Xiye Bastida, la ‘Greta Thunberg de América’, reprende a líderes en cumbre climática. Forbes México. [Online]. April 22. [Accessed August 4, 2022]. Available from: https://www. forbes.com.mx/mexicana-xiye-bastida-reprende-lideres-cumbre-clima/.
Sturgeon, N. 1999. Ecofeminist Appropriations and Transnational Environmentalisms. Identities 6(2–3), 255–279. doi:10.1080/1070289X.1999.9962645.
Taft, J. K. 2020. Hopeful, Harmless, and Heroic: Figuring the Girl Activist as Global Savior. Girlhood Studies, (13)2, 1–17. doi:10.3167/ghs.2020.130203
Thunberg, G. 2019. No One Is Too Small to Make A Difference. 2nd edition. New York: Penguin Random House.
Tuana, N. 2019. Climate Apartheid: The Forgetting of Race in the Anthropocene. Critical Philosophy of Race. 7(1), 1–31.
Unigwe, C. 2019. It’s Not Just Greta Thunberg: Why Are We Ignoring the Developing World’s Inspiring Activists? - Young People in the Global South Have Been Tackling the Climate Crisis for Years. They Should Be Celebrated Too. The Guardian. October 5, 5.
Vowles, K., and Hultman, M. 2021. Dead White men vs. Greta Thunberg: Nationalism, Misogyny, and Climate Change Denial in Swedish far-right Digital Media. Australian Feminist Studies 36, 414–431. https://doi.org/10.1080/08164649.2022.2062669
Vu, H. T., Liu, Y., and Tran, D. V. 2019. Nationalizing a Global Phenomenon: A Study of How the Press in 45 Countries and Territories Portrays Climate Change. Global Environmental Change. 58(September), 101942. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2019.101942.
Wahlström, M. and Uba, K.. 2023. Political Icon and Role Model: Dimensions of the Perceived ‘Greta Effect’ among Climate Activists as Aspects of Contemporary Social Movement Leadership. Acta Sociologica. doi:10.1177/00016993231204215
Warren, C. and Clayton, D. 2020. Climate change, COP26 and the Crucible of Crisis: Editorial Introduction to the Special Issue. Scottish Geographical Journal 136(1–4), 1–4. doi: 10.1080/14702541.2020.1874645.
White, M. 2021. Greta Thunberg is ‘Giving a Face’ to Climate Activism: Confronting Anti-Feminist, Anti- Environmentalist, and Ableist Memes. Australian Feminist Studies 36, 396–413. https://doi.org/10.1080/08164649.2022.2062667
Downloads
Publiceret
Citation/Eksport
Nummer
Sektion
Licens
Copyright (c) 2024 Jenna Coughlin, Ana Paulina Morera Quesada
Dette værk er under følgende licens Creative Commons Navngivelse –Ikke-kommerciel (by-nc).
Udgivelser i Kvinder, Køn og Forskning er beskyttet under Creative Commons License: CC Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0
