An analysis of two 19th century Norwegian geometry books, and the reactions they caused
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7146/nomad.v20i3-4.148691Abstract
Bernt Michael Holmboe (1795–1850), professor in mathematics, wrote several textbooks on mathematics, and his presentation of geometry was traditional and in conformity with Euclidean ideas. Christopher Hansteen (1784–1873), professor in applied mathematics, wrote a textbook on geometry where he challenged the traditional Euclidean geometry. This paper analyses two very different approaches to basic definitions in the two geometry textbooks written by Holmboe and Hansteen, and what reactions this caused in the contemporary society. The main focus will be on the understanding of basic concepts in geometry, and of parallel lines and Euclid’s parallel postulate.
References
Andersen, O. (1914). Norges høiere skolevæsen 1814-1914. En oversigt (Kirke- og undervisningsdepartementets jubilæumsskrifter 1914). Kristiania: J. M. Stenersens forlag.
Bjarnadóttir, K., Christiansen, A. & Lepik, M. (2013). Arithmetic textbooks in Estonia, Iceland and Norway - similarities and differences during the nineteenth century. Nordic Studies in Mathematics Education, 18 (3), 27-58.
Christiansen, A. (2008). A hermeneutic perspective on analyzing historical textbooks. In I. Witzke (Ed.), 18th novembertagung on the history, philosophy & didactics of mathematics. Mathematical practice & development throughout history (pp. 115-130). Bonn: Logos Verlag Berlin.
Christiansen, A. (2009). Bernt Michael Holmboe (1795-1850) and his mathematics textbooks. BSHM Bulletin: Journal of the British Society for the History of Mathematics, 24, 105-113. https://doi.org/10.1080/17498430902820895
Christiansen, A. (2010). Bernt Michael Holmboe's textbooks and the development of mathematical analysis in the 19th century. In E. Barbin, M. Kronfellner & C. Tzanakis (Eds.), History and epistemology in mathematics education. Proceedings of the sixth European Summer University (pp. 653-663). Wien: Verlag Holzhausen GmbH.
Christiansen, A. (2012a). A controversy about geometry textbooks in Norway 1835-36. In K. Bjarnadóttir, F. Furinghetti, J. M. Matos & G. Schubring (Eds.), "Dig where you stand" 2. Proceedings on the second "International Conference on the History of Mathematics Education" (pp. 117-128). Lisbon: UIED.
Christiansen, A. (2012b). Geometry textbooks in Norway in the first half of the 19th century. In HPM2012. The HPM Satellite Meeting of ICME-12 (pp. 683-692). Daejeon: HPM.
Den Constitutionelle (1836). Reviews, replies and notices (25 June 1836, 16 July 1836, 4 August 1836, 21 August 1836, 23 August 1836, 24 August 1836, 19 September 1836 and 22 September 1836). Accessible on microfilm.
Euclid (1956). The thirteen books of the Elements (Volume I-III). (Translated with introduction and commentary by Sir Thomas L. Heath. Unabridged and unaltered republication of the Second Edition from 1925. First edition 1908). New York: Dover Publications.
Ewald, W. (2005). From Kant to Hilbert: a source book in the foundations of mathematics (Volume I & II). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oso/9780198505365.001.0001
Gray, J. (2008). Geometry. In The Princeton companion to mathematics (Chapter II.2, pp. 83-95). Princeton University Press. https://doi.org/10.1515/9781400830398.83
Greenberg, M. J. (2008). Euclidean and non-Euclidean geometries (4th ed.). New York: W.H. Freeman and Company.
Hansteen, C. (1835). Lærebog i plangeometrie. Christiania: Johan Dahl. Hansteen, C. (1836). Belysning af Hr. Professor B. Holmboes anmeldelse af min Plangeometrie, Morgenbladet No. 339, 5 Dec 1835. Christiania: Johan Dahl.
Holmboe, B. M. (1827). Lærebog i mathematiken. Anden deel, inneholdende begyndelsesgrundene til geometrien (1st ed.). Christiania: Jacob Lehman.
Holmboe, B. M. (1833). Lærebog i mathematiken. Anden deel, inneholdende begyndelsesgrundene til geometrien (2nd ed.). Christiania; Jacob Abelsted.
Holmboe, B. M. (1836). Gjenmæle fremkaldt ved Hr. Professor Hansteens belysning af min anmeldelse af hans lærebog i geometrien. Christiania: Jacob C. Abelsted.
Katz, V. J. (2009). A history of mathematics. An introduction (3rd ed.). Boston: Addison Wesley.
Kunnskapsforlaget (2006). Store norske leksikon. Oslo: Kunnskapsforlaget.
Legendre, A.-M. (1817). Éléments de géométrie, avec des notes. (Onzième Édition). Paris.
Morgenbladet (1835). Reviews, replies and notices (5 December 1835, 13 December 1835, 15 December 1835, 16 December 1835, 18 December 1835, 23 December 1835, 25 December 1835, 28 December 1835, 5 January 1836 and 21 January 1836). Retrieved from www.nb.no/avis
Solvang, R. (2001). Skolematematikken i Norge på Abels tid. Nordisk Matematisk Tidsskrift, 49 (3), 111-138.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
