The importance of the “right to the truth” in El-Masri case: Lessons learned from the extraordinary rendition

Authors

  • Vesna Stefanovska Legal researcher in the Institute for Human Rights, North Macedonia and Associate Editor in the professional law journal “Legal Dialogue” issued by the Institute for Human Rights

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v32i3.128147

Keywords:

extraordinary rendition, torture, interrogation, right to the truth and national security.

Abstract

Introduction: In December 2012 the European Court of Human Rights (the Court or ECtHR) delivered the landmark decision in the case of El-Masri v. F.Y.R Macedonia (‘Macedonia’) ruling that CIA extraordinary rendition program amounts to torture. Macedonia was held responsible for torture and detention of El-Masri; lack of conducting effective interrogation; lack of request for diplomatic assurances from CIA agents and interference with the right to private and family life. Some of the judges referred to the right of the truth as the right of El-Masri to be familiar with the facts why he was held incommunicado and being subject of the CIA extraordinary rendition program. Objective: By using the El-Masri v. Macedonia case, this paper aims to map the necessity for protection of human rights even when national security and war against terrorism are at stake. The right to the truth should be of utmost importance besides proving torture –it is the way for the victim to accomplish moral victory and to gather all facts of the case. Method: The relevant texts were gathered from the HUDOC database, Cambridge University Press, Google Scholar, while interviews were conducted with Margarita Tsatsa Nikolovska – former judge in the European Court of Human Rights and Aleksandar Bozinovski – the journalist who discovered to the public the extraordinary rendition of Khaled El-Masri. Results/Discussion: the ruling in the El-Masri case was the first time when an international court held that the CIA’s extraordinary rendition program amounts to torture. However, the Court did not argue about the culpability of CIA agents nor the explanations how Macedonia can be held accountable for torture committed in a foreign country by foreign agents just because of lack of diplomatic assurances and allowed extraordinary rendition at the Skopje Airport.

Author Biography

Vesna Stefanovska, Legal researcher in the Institute for Human Rights, North Macedonia and Associate Editor in the professional law journal “Legal Dialogue” issued by the Institute for Human Rights

Correspondence to: vesna.stefanovska87@gmail.com

References

Anwukah, O.J. (2016). The Effectiveness of International Law: Torture and Counterterrorism. Annual Survey of International & Comparative Law 21(1), 1-29

Council of Europe. (2006). Report by the Secretary General under Article 52 of the Convention on the question of secret detention and transport of detainees suspected of terrorist acts (SG/Inf 2006, 5, 28 February 2006) State of play in respect of question 4 (googleusercontent.com)

ECtHR (2012). El-Masri v. the F.Y.R Macedonia, 39630/09, 13 December 2012

El-Masri v. Tenet, Case No. 1:05cv1417, E.D.Va. 21 March 2006.

European Parliament (2006). German Prosecutor tells MEPs he has no evidence contradicting El-Masri abduction claim. European Parliament Press Service, Director – Spokesperson Jaume Duch Guillot CIA-munich-prosecutor-El-Masri-11-07-06.pdf (statewatch.org)

European Parliament. (2006). The Fava Inquiry on the alleged use of European countries by the CIA for the transportation and illegal detention of prisoners (2006/2200(INI)) Report on the alleged use of European countries by the CIA for the transportation and illegal detention of prisoners (europa.eu)

Fabbrini, F. (2013). The European Court of Human Rights, Extraordinary Renditions and the Right to theTruth: Ensuring Accountability for Gross Human Rights Violations Committed in the Fight Against Terrorism. Human Rights Law Review (2013) 1-26. doi:10.1093/ h rl r/ngt 017

Hadji-Janev, M. (2013). Legal aspect of intelligence gathering through extraordinary rendition operations In book: Shaping The Security Environment Western Balkans and Beyond (pp.55-69), Ministry of Defense of the Republic of Macedonia, Editors: Stephen R. Di Rienzo, Ferdinand Odzakov

Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (2016). Report No. 21/16, Case Petition 419-08. Admissibility. Khaled El-Masri. United States. April 15, 2016. USAD419-08EN.pdf (oas.org)

Nolikaember, A. (2012). The ECtHR Finds Macedonia Responsible in Connection with Torture by the CIA, but on What Basis? EJILTalk The ECtHR Finds Macedonia Responsible in Connection with Torture by the CIA, but on What Basis? – EJIL: Talk! (ejiltalk.org)

Orpiszewska, M. (2013). El Masri v. Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia: Implications for the CIA Extraordinary Rendition Program, 39 N.C. J. Int'l L. & Com. Reg. 1165-1194.

Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. (2006). Marty Report on alleged secret detentions and unlawful inter-State transfers of detainees involving Council of Europe member States, Doc. 10957, 12 June 2006. Microsoft Word - ajdoc16 2006 Part II-FINAL1.doc (coe.int)

Redress - Ending Torture seeking Justice for Survivors. (2016). Litigating Torture and Ill-treatment in East Africa A Manual for Practitioners Litigating Torture and Ill-Treatment in the Middle East & North Africa: A Manual for Practitioners | Redress

Scott, E. (2015). The State Secret Privilege: Alternative Remedies in Cases of Torture Abroad. Southwestern Law Review 45(1), 219-240.

Senate Select Committee on Intelligence Committee Study (2014). Report of the Central Intelligence Agency’s Detention and Interrogation Program Together with Foreword by Chairman Feinstein and Additional and Minority Views, unclassified. https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/sites/default/files/documents/CRPT-113srpt288.pdf

Swanidze, E. (2018). Expert Opinion on Definition of Torture and Ill-Treatment and Statute of Limitation DGI (2018) 12, Directorate of Human Rights Human Rights Policy and Co-Operation Department, https://rm.coe.int/2019-comparative-analysis-on-macedonian-criminal-code-eng/168091f5ce

Tucker, K. (2014). Abduction, Torture, Interrogation – Oh My! – An Argument against Extraordinary rendition. Revista di Direito Internacional – Brazilian Journal of International Law 10 (2), 141-155

United Nations (2009). Report of the UN Special Rapporteur on the Promotion and Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms while Countering Terrorism A/HRC/10/3, 4 February 2009, OHCHR | Special Rapporteur on Terrorism - Annual Reports

Weissbrodt, D. & Bergquist, A. (2006). Extraordinary Rendition: A Human Rights Analysis, 19. Harvard Human Rights Journal 19,123-160.

Downloads

Published

2021-12-29

How to Cite

Stefanovska, V. (2021). The importance of the “right to the truth” in El-Masri case: Lessons learned from the extraordinary rendition. Torture Journal, 31(3), 59–69. https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v32i3.128147