Survivors’ experiences with testifying in trials after gross human rights violations in Argentina
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v32i3.125118Keywords:
Enforced disappearances - trials - testimony - ArgentinaAbstract
In Argentina, persons who were held detained-disappeared during the last military dictatorship (1976 - 1983) now testify in trials related to the military regime’s use of enforced disappearances, torture and other crimes. The trials were re-initiated in 2005, after more than a decade of impunity. Trials have been taking place all over the country since then. Trials are related either to individual perpetrators, individual victims, or to places where the crimes were committed. Many witnesses testify in a number of trials. In this article, I explore experiences with testifying in these trials, based on interviews with 23 persons who were held ‘detained-disappeared’ for political reasons during the dictatorship. The witnesses have testified both to what they themselves have endured, and to crimes committed towards persons who remain forcefully disappeared.
The testimonies of persons who were held detained-disappeared are central in the trials, as there is often little evidence besides these testimonies. The interviewees express a strong sense of responsibility related to testifying in court, due to the central role of these testimonies as well as the witnesses’ responsibility towards those who remain forcefully disappeared or were killed. Through testimonies in court, persons who remain forcefully disappeared are presented as persons with agency and often with a political commitment; not only as victims of serious violations of human rights.
I discuss testimonies in court as a longer process, which begins before the trial is initiated and where the testimony itself is the main event. To testify in court may lead to distress, and there is a worry about re-traumatisation. Several aspects of trials have an influence on the experience with testifying, among them the presence and attitude of the defendants; the presence of threats, the ways in which questions are asked during testimonies, and how many trials the witness has testified in.
References
Arnoso, M., Ansaloni, S., Gandarias, I., & Arnoso, A. (2012). Mujeres jujeñas y sobrevivientes: Narrativas del pasado represivo (1976—1983) argentino, consecuencias psicosociales y creencias acerca de la represión. [Women survivors of Jujuy: narratives about the Argentine repressive past, psychosocial consequences and understandings of the repression] Revista Mexicana de Sciencias Politicas y Sociales, 57(214). http://www.scielo.org.mx/scielo.php?pid=S0185-19182012000100006&script=sci_arttext
Arnoso Martinez, M., Muratori, M., Bombelli, J., & Zubieta, E. (2017). Evaluación de medidas retributivas y restrauratorias luego de pasados políticos traumáticos: Una mirada al caso argentino. [Evaluation of retributive and restorative measures after traumatic political pasts: the Argentine case] Cuadernos FHyCS-UNJu, 52, 211–233.
Braun, V., & Clarke, V. (2006). Using thematic analysis in psychology. Qualitative Research in Psychology, 3(2), 77–101.
Calveiro, P. (2008). Poder y desaparición. Los campos de desaparición en la Argentina. [Power and disappearance. The disappearance camps in Argentina] Colihue.
Charters, S., & Vahidy, S. (2009). Testifying in an International War Crimes Tribunal: The Experience of Witnesses in the Special Court for Sierra Leone. The International Journal of Transitional Justice, 3, 135–149.
Ciorciari, John. D., & Heindel, A. (2016). Victim Testimony in International and Hybrid Criminal Courts: Narrative Opportunities, Challenges, and Fair Trial. Virginia Journal of International Law, vol 56(2).
CONADEP. (1984). Nunca Más. Informe de la Comisión Nacional sobre desaparición de personas. [Never again. Report of the National Commission on the disappearance of persons] Editorial Universitaria de Buenos Aires/Comisión Nacional sobre la Desaparición de Personas.
Crenzel, E. (2012). From judicial truth to historical knowledge: The disappearance of persons in Argentina. In B. Syndercombe (Ed.), New Beginnings: Argentina & South Africa (Vol. 3, pp. 53–64). AfricaRethoric Publishing. http://www.africanrhetoric.org/pdf/10_AYOR%203,2%20Martin.pdf
Crenzel, E. (2018). Inside ‘State Terrorism’: Bureaucracies and Social Attitudes in Response to Enforced Disappearance of Persons in Argentina. Journal of Human Rights Practice, 10, 268–286.
Crenzel, E. (2020). Four Cases under Examination: Human Rights and Justice in Argentina under the Macri Administration. Modern Languages Open, 1(26), 1–13.
Edelman, L. (2010). Testigos. [Witnesses] In D. Kordon, L. Edelman, D. Lagos, & D. Kersner (Eds.), Sur, dictadura y después... [South, Dictatorship and afterwards...] Psicolibro ediciones.
Fletcher, L. E., & Weinstein, H. M. (2002). Violence and Social Repair: Rethinking the Contribution of Justice to Reconciliation. Human Rights Quarterly, 24(3), 573–639. https://doi.org/10.1353/hrq.2002.0033
Guembe, M. J. (2005). La reapertura de los juicios por los crímenes de la dictadura militar Argentina/Reopening of trials for crimes committed by the Argentine military dictatorship. Sur - Rede Universitária de Direitos Humanos, 2(3). https://www.scielo.br/j/sur/a/bWtD5YyMb8JWgry5xbCy3bL/abstract/?lang=es
Hamber, B. (2009). Transforming Societies after Political Violence. Truth, Reconciliation, and Mental Health. Springer.
Hamber, B., Nageng, D., & O’Malley, G. (2000). “Telling it like it is...”: Understanding the Truth and reconciliation commission from the perspective of survivors. Psychology in Society, 26, 18–42.
Herman, J. L. (2003). The Mental Health of Crime Victims: Impact of Legal Intervention. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 16(2), 159. Academic Search Ultimate.
Herman, J. L. (2005). Justice From the Victim’s Perspective. Violence Against Women, 11(5), 571–602.
Horn, R., Charters, S., & Vahidy, S. (2009). Witnesses in the special court for Sierra Leone: The importance of the witness–lawyer relationship. International Journal of Law, Crime & Justice, 37(1/2), 25–38.
Horn, R., Vahidy, S., & Charters, S. (2011). Testifying in the Special Court for Sierra Leone: Witness perceptions of safety and emotional welfare. Psychology, Crime & Law, 17(5).
Jelin, E. (2010). Victimas, familiares o ciudadanos/as? Las luchas por la legitimidad de la palabra.[Victims, relatives or citizens? The struggle for the legitimacy of the word] In E. Crenzel (Ed.), Los desaparecidos en la Argentina. Memorias, representaciones e ideas (1983-2008). [The disappeared in Argentina. Memories, representations, and ideas] Editorial Biblos.
Kersner, D. (2002). Los derechos humanos en la Argentina de hoy.[Human Rights in Contemporary Argentina] In D. Kersner, M. A. Jorge, C. Madariaga, & A. Martin (Eds.), Pasajes del dolor, Senderos de esperanza. Salud mental y derechos humanos en el cono sur.[Passages of pain, paths of hope. Mental health and human rights in the Southern Cone] EATIP.
King, K. L., & Meernik, J. D. (2017). The Witness Experience: Testimony at the ICTY and Its Impact. Cambridge University Press.
King, K., & Meernik, James. (2019). The Burden of Bearing Witness. The impact of of testifying at war crimes tribunals. Journal of Conflict Resolution, 63(2), 348–372.
Kordon, D., Edelman, L., Lagos, D., & Kersner, D. (Eds.). (2010). Sur, dictadura y después.[South, dictatorship, and after...] Psicolibro ediciones.
Lagos, M. (2010). Juicios a represores.[Trials against repressors] In D. Kordon, L. Edelman, D. Lagos, & D. Kersner (Eds.), Sur, dictadura y después... (pp. 114–125). Psicolibro
Martín-Beristain, C., Páez, D., Rimé, B., & Kanyangara, P. (2010). Psychosocial effects of participation in rituals of transitional justice: A collective-level analysis and review of the literature of the effects of TRCs and trials on human rights violations in Latin America. International Journal of Social Psychology, 25(1), 47–60. https://doi.org/10.1174/021347410790193450
Ministerio Fiscal Público de la República Argentina. (2021, June 16). Estado actual del proceso de juzgamiento.[The current status of the process of trials] Fiscales.Gob.Ar. https://www.fiscales.gob.ar/lesa-humanidad/estado-actual-del-proceso-de-juzgamiento-256-sentencias-y-1030-personas-condenadas-en-causas-por-crimenes-de-lesa-humanidad/
Minow, M. (1998). Between Vengeance and Forgiveness. Facing History after Genocides and Mass Violence. Beacon Press.
O’Donnell, G. (2010). Democracia, agencia y estado. Teoría con intención comparativa. [Democracy, Agency and State. Theory with comparative intent] Prometeo libros.
Roht-Arriaza, N. (2013). Editorial Note. International Journal of Transitional Justice, 7, 383–392.
Rosende, L., & Pertot, W. (2013). Los días sin López. El testigo desaparecido en democracia. Planeta.
Secretaria de derechos humanos. (2021, August 3). Juicios de Lesa Humanidad en tiempo real. Juicios de Lesa Humanidad En Tiempo Real. http://www.juiciosdelesahumanidad.ar/#!/
Snodgrass Godoy, A. (2018). Making Meaning of Violence: Human Rights and historical memory in the conflict in El Salvador. Journal of Human Rights, 17(3), 367–379.
Stein, D. J., Seedat, S., Kaminer, D., Moomal, H., Herman, A., Sonnega, J., & Williams, D. R. (2008). The impact of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission on psychological distress and forgiveness in South Africa. Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology, 43(6), 462–468.
Stepakoff, S., Reynolds, S., Charters, S., & Henry, N. (2005). The Experience of Testifying in a War-Crimes Tribunal in Sierra Leone. American Psychological Association, 2(3), 445–464.
Stover, E. (2005). The Witnesses. War crimes and the Promise of Justice in the Hague. University of Pennsylvania Press.
Sveaass, N., & Sønneland, A. M. (2015). Dealing with the Past: Survivors’ Perspectives on Economic Reparations in Argentina. International Perspectives in Psychology: Research, Practice, Consultation, 4(4), 223–238.
Varsky, C. (2011). El testimonio como prueba en procesos penales por delitos de lesa humanidad. Algunas reflexiones sobre su importancia en el proceso de justicia argentino.[Testimony as proof in legal processes after crimes against humanity. Some reflexions on ther importance in the Argentine process of justice] In Hacer justicia. Nuevos debates sobre el juzgamiento de crímenes de lesa humanidad en la Argentina. [Creating justice. New debates about the trials in cases of crimes against humanity] Siglo Veintiuno Editores.
Walling, C. B. (2018). Insights on victim testimony and transitional justice: A response to Angelina Snodgrass Godoy. Journal of Human Rights, 17(3), 384–391. Academic Search Elite.
Wilson, R. A. (2009). The politics of truth and reconciliation in South Africa. Legitimizing the Post-Apartheid State. Cambridge University Press.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2021 Torture Journal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
We accept that some authors (e.g. government employees in some countries) are unable to transfer copyright. The Creative Commons Licence Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) covers both the Torture Journal and the IRCT web site. The publisher will not put any limitation on the personal freedom of the author to use material contained in the paper in other works which may be published, provided that acknowledgement is made to the original place of publication.
