Protocol on medico-legal documentation of solitary confinement

Authors

  • Marie Brasholt Dignity
  • Nora Sveaass Psychologist, Department of Psychology, Oslo University
  • Pau Pérez Sales Clinical Director. SiRa Center, Madrid
  • Hugo Marboeuf
  • Ergün Cakal PhD Fellow, Law Faculty, Copenhagen University
  • Elna Søndergaard DIGNITY - Danish Institute against Torture

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v33i1.130739

Keywords:

Solitary Confinement, Medico-Legal Documentation, Psychological Torture, Istanbul Protocol

Abstract

Introduction. This Protocol originates from
a joint project regarding documentation of
psychological torture initiated by the Public
Committee against Torture in Israel (PCATI),
REDRESS and DIGNITY - Danish Institute
Against Torture (DIGNITY) in 2015 after
the Copenhagen Conference on Psychological
Torture. The project is a vehicle to establish
a common understanding between health
and legal professions as to how to best ensure
the most accurate documentation of torture.
The aim of the Protocol is to improve documentation
of solitary confinement and therefore
to clarify the facts of the case so that
stronger legal claims can subsequently be submitted
to local and international complaints
mechanisms. The Protocol has been developed
based on a methodology involving a compilation
and review of legal and health knowledge
on solitary confinement and discussions
among the authors and in a group of international
experts.
Methods and Results. This Protocol is
cognisant of the significance of the specific
social, cultural and political contexts in which
solitary confinement is used. We hope that this
Protocol will assist in the discussions between
the various stakeholders and provide guidance
on what can be documented and how to document
torture.

References

Akil, H. (2019). The Brain in Isolation: A

Neuroscientist’s Perspective on Solitary

Confinement’. In Jules Lobel, and Peter Scharff

Smith (eds), Solitary Confinement: Effects,

Practices, and Pathways toward Reform. New

York, 2019; online edn, Oxford Academic,

Dec. 2019. https://doi.org/10.1093/

oso/9780190947927.003.0012

African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights,

Krishna Achuthan and Amnesty International

(on behalf of Aleke Banda and Orton and Vera

Chirwa) v. Malawi, No. 64/92, 68/92 and 78/92,

judgement of 22 March 1995.

African Commission on Human and Peoples’ Rights,

Media Rights Agenda (on behalf of Niran

Malaolu) v. Nigeria, No. 224/98, judgement of 6

November 2000.

Bottom of Form

Andersen, H.S., Sestoft, D., Lillebaek, T.,

Gabrielsen, G., Hemmingsen, R., & Kramp, P.

(2000). A longitudinal study of prisoners on

remand: psychiatric prevalence, incidence and

psychopathology in solitary vs. non-solitary

confinement. Acta Psychiatr Scand., Jul 102(1),

–25.

Andersen, H.S. et al. (2003). A longitudinal study

of prisoners on remand: repeated measures of

psychopathology in the initial phase of solitary

versus non-solitary confinement. International

Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 26, 165–177.

Ashker v. Governor of California, Civil Action No.

:09-cv-05796-CW (N.D. California), settlement

of the case (1 September 2015).

Brinkley-Rubinstein, L., Sivaraman, J., Rosen, D.L.,

Cloud, D.H., Junker, G., Proescholdbell, S.,

Shanahan, M.E. & Ranapurwala, S.I. (2019).

Association of Restrictive Housing During

Incarceration With Mortality After Release.

JAMA Network Open, 2(10).

British Columbia Civil Liberties Association and

John Howard Society v. Attorney General of

Canada, (2018), B.C.J. No. 53, 2018 BCSC 62.

Bronwyn, N. & Shalev, S. (2022), Solitary

Confinement and the Meaning of “Meaningful

Human Contract”, Chapter 10, Herrera, C.B

and Haeck, Y (eds), Human Rights Behind Bars:

Tracing Vulnerability in Prison Populations

Across Continents from a Multidisciplinary

Perspective, Springer Cham.

Cacioppo J.T. & Hawkley L.C. (2009). Perceived

Social Isolation and Cognition. Trends Cogn Sci.

Oct; 13(10): 447–454.

Certain Children by their Litigation Guardian Sister

Marie Brigid Arthur v Minister for Families and

Children & Others [No 2] (2017) 52 VR.

Cloud, D.H., Ahalt, C., Augustine, D., Sears, D.,

& Williams, B. (2020). Medical Isolation and

Solitary Confinement: Balancing Health and

Humanity in US Jails and Prisons During

COVID-19. J Gen Intern Med; 35: 2738–2742.

Coppola, F. (2019). The brain in solitude: an

(other) eighth amendment challenge to solitary

confinement. Journal of Law and the Biosciences,

–42 doi:10.1093/jlb/lsz014 Advance Access

Publication.

DIGNITY – Danish Institut against Torture,

Conference Report 2017 Solitary Confinement

used as a Disciplinary Measure

European Committee on the Prevention of Torture.

(2011). Standards: Solitary Confinement of

Prisoners.

European Committee on the Prevention of Torture.

(2011). Report on the Visit to Spain, CPT/Inf

(2013)/6.

European Committee on the Prevention of Torture.

(2011). 21st General Report, CPT/Inf (2011).

European Committee on the Prevention of Torture.

(2015). General Reports, CPT/Inf/E, 1 - Rev.

ECtHR. (2005). Ribitsch v Austria, 18896/91

ECtHR. (2006). Ramirez Sanchez v. France, 59450/00

ECtHR. (2005). Mathew v. the Netherlands, 24919/03

ECHR. (2010). A.B. v. Russia, 1439/06

ECHR. (1997). Raninen v. Finland. 20972/92

ECHR. (1999). Selmouni v. France. 25803/94

ECtHR. (2004). Ilaşcu and others v. Moldova and

Russia, No. 48787/99

ECtHR. (2009). Ramishvili and Kokhreidze v. Georgia,

/06

ECtHR. (2011). Payet v. France, 19606/08

ECtHR. (2012). Piechowicz v. Poland, 20071/07

ECtHR (2014). Gorbulya v. Russia, 31535/09

ECtHR. (2020. N.T. v. Russia, 4727/11

European Prison Rules (2020), Recommendation

Rec(2006)2, revised and amended by the

Committee of Ministers of the Council of

Europe on 1 July 2020.

Gamman, T. (1995). Solitary Confinement and

Influence on Inmates Health. Tidsskr Nor

Lægeforen. 1995: 2243–6.

Gamman, T. (2001). Om bruk av isolasjon under

varetektsfengsling. Nordisk Tidsskrift for

Kriminalvidenskab 2001: 88.

Gendreau, P. et al. (1972). Changes in EEG Alpha

Frequency and Evoked Response Latency

During Solitary Confinement. Journal of

Abnormal Psychology, 79 (1): 54-59.

Haney, C. (2003). Mental Health Issues in Long

Term Solitary and “Supermax” Confinement.

Crime Delinquency, Vol. 49 (1): 124–156.

Haney, C. (2012). Expert Report in Ashker v.

Governor of California, Civil Action No. 4:09-cv-

-CW (N.D. California).

Hebb, D. (1961). Introduction to Chapter 2,

Cognitive and Physiological Effects of Perceptual

Isolation. In Ph. Solomon et al. (eds). Sensory

Deprivation. An investigation of Phenomena

Suggesting a Revised Concept of the Individual’s

response to His Environment, pp. 6-33. Cambridge:

Harvard University Press.

Heron, W. (1957). The pathology of boredom.

Scientific American, Vol. 196: 52–56.

Heron, W. (1961). Cognitive and Physiological

Effects of Perceptual Isolation. In Ph. Solomon

et al. (eds). Sensory Deprivation, pp. 6 – 33.

Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Hodgins, S. & Cote, G. (1991). The mental health of

penitentiary inmates in isolation. Can J Criminol.

(Apr 91):175–182.

Inter-American Commission on Human Rights,

Resolution 1/08, Principles and Best Practices on

the Protection of Persons Deprived of Liberty in

the Americas, 13 March 2008.

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Velázquez-

Rodríguez v. Honduras, Series C, No. 4, ,

judgement of 29 July 1988.

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Víctor

Rosario Congo v. Ecuador, Case 11.427,

judgement of 12 March 1997.

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Loayza-

Tamayo v. Peru, Series C, No. 33, judgement 17

September 1997.

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Castillo

Petruzzi et al. v. Peru, Series C, No. 52,

judgement of 30 May 1999.

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Cantoral-

Benavides v. Peru, Series C, No. 69, 18 August

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Miguel

Castro-Castro Prison v. Peru, Series C, No. 160,

judgement of 25 November 2006

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Montero-

Aranguren et al. (Detention Center of Catia) v.

Venezuela, Series C No. 150, Judgement of 5

July 2006

Inter-American Court on Human Rights, Report

on the Human Rights of Persons Deprived of

Liberty in the Americas, OEA/Ser.L/V/II. Doc.

, 31 December 2011.

The Istanbul Statement on the Use and Effects of

Solitary Confinement (2007).

Jackson, M. (1983). Prisoners of Isolation: Solitary

Confinement in Canada. Toronto: Toronto

University Press.

Kaba, F-, Lewis, A., Glowa-Kollisch, S., Hadler,

J., Lee, D., Alper, H., et al (1972). Solitary

Confinement and Risk of Self-Harm Among

Jail Inmates. American Journal of Public Health |

March 2014, Vol 104 (3).

Korn, R. (1988). The Effects of Confinement in

the High Security Unit at Lexington. Social

Justice Vol. 15, No. 1 (31), Struggles for Justice

(Spring 1988), pp. 8-19, https://www.jstor.org/

stable/29766384.

Leiderman, P.H., Mendelson, J., Wexler, D., &

Solomon, P. (1958). Sensory deprivation:

Clinical aspects. AMA Arch Intern Med.

;101(2):389-396, doi:10.1001/

archinte.1958.00260140221032.

Lobel, J. & Smith, P.S. (eds.) (2020). Solitary

Confinement, Effects, Practices, and Pathways

towards Reform, Oxford University Press.

Mc Coy, A.W. (2008). Legacy of a Dark Decade: CIA

Mind Control, Classified Behavioral lResearch,

and the Origins of Modern Medical Ethics. In

A.E. Ojeda (ed). The Trauma of Psychological

Torture, pp 40-70. London: Praeger.

Miller, H.A., & Young, G.R. (1997). Prison

segregation: administrative detention remedy

or mental health problem? Crim Behav Ment

Health.7(1):85–94.

Perez-Sales, P. (2017), Psychological Torture. Definition,

evaluation and measurement. New York: Routledge.

Pérez-Sales, P., Søndergaard, E., Shir, E., Cakal, E.,

& Brasholt, M. (2019). Protocol on Medico-

Legal Documentation of Sleep Deprivation.

Torture Journal, 29(2), 28-55.

Penal Reform International and Essex Human Rights

Centre, Essex paper 3: Initial guidance on the

interpretation and implementation of the UN

Nelson Mandela Rules (2017).

Roma, P., Pompili, M., Lester, D., Girardi, P., &

Ferracuti, S. (2013) Incremental conditions of

isolation as a predictor of suicide in prisoners.

Forensic Sci Int. (2013 Dec 10);233(1):e1–2.

Royal Commission into Aboriginal deaths in custody.

(1991). Volume 3 AURoyalC 3, 15 April 1991.

Ruff, G.E., Levy, E.Z. & Thaler, V.H. (1961). Factors

Influencing the Reaction to Reduced Sensory

Output. In Ph. Solomon et al. (eds). Sensory

Deprivation. An investigation of Phenomena

Suggesting a Revised Concept of the Individual’s

response to His Environment, pp. 72-91.

Cambridge: Harvard University Press.

Ruiz v. Texas, 137 S. Ct. 1246, 1247 (2017).

Sestoft D.M., Andersen H.S., Lillebaek T, Gabrielsen

G (1998). Impact of solitary confinement

on hospitalization among Danish prisoners

in custody. Int J Law Psychiatry, Winter

;21(1):99-108. doi: 10.1016/s0160-

(97)00025-3.

Smith, P.S. (2006). The Effects of Solitary

Confinement on Prison Inmates: A brief history

and review of literature. Crime and Justice, vol. 34,

-528.

Smith, P.S. & Koch, I. (2019). Isolationens

følgevirkninger – fra 1800-tallet til i dag. In M.

Rus & P.S. Smith (2019). Isolasjon – et fengsel i

fengslet. Pp. 109 – 139. Copenhagen: Cappelen

Damm Akademisk.

Stang, J., Moe, J, Teigst, I.A., Østberg, B., &

Moger, T. (2003). Fanger i sikkerhetscelle – en

utfordring. Tidsskr Nor Lægeforen nr. 13–14,

; 123: pp. 1844–6.

Stang, J. & Østberg, B. (2006). Innsattes forslag til å

forebygge isolasjon i sikkerhetscelle. Tidsskrift for

Norsk psykologforening, Vol 43, nummer 1, 2006,

pp. 30-33.

Strong, J.D., Reiter, K., Gonzalez, G., Tublitz, R.,

Augustine, D., Barragan. M., et al. (2020) The

body in isolation: The physical health impacts

of incarceration in solitary confinement. PLoS

ONE 15 (10): e0238510. https://doi.org/10.1371/

journal. pone.0238510.

Sveaass, N. (2009). Torture – a Crime against

Humanity. In A. Lothe, M. Daniel, M.B.

Snipstad & N. Sveaass (eds). Strength in Broken

Places. Marginalisation and Empowerment, pp. 179-

, Oslo.

Søndergaard, E., Skilbeck, R., & Shir, E. (2019).

Development of interdisciplinary protocols on

medico-legal documentation of torture: Sleep

deprivation. Torture Journal, 29(2), pp. 23-27.

United Nations Committee against Torture,

Bouabdallah Ltaief v. Tunisia, CAT/

C/31/D/189/2001, 14 November 2003.

United Nations Committee against Torture, Imed

Abdelli v. Tunisia, CAT/C/31/D/188/2001, 14

November 2003.

United Nations Committee against Torture, Report

of the Inquiry on Turkey, A/48/44/ADD.1, 15

November 1993.

United Nations Committee on Human Rights, Daley

v. Jamaica, CCPR/C/63/D/750/1997. 3 August

United Nations Committee on Human Rights, Evans

v. Trinidad and Tobago, CCPR/C/77/D/908/2000,

May 2003

United Nations Committee on Human Rights, Yong-

Joo Kang v. Republic of South Korea, CCPR/

C/78/D/878/1999, 16 July 2003.

United Nations Committee on Human Rights,

General Comment 7, Article 7 (1982).

United Nations Committee for the Rights of the

Child, Concluding Observations on El Salvador,

CRC/C/15/Add.232, 30 June 2004.

United Nations Committee for the Rights of the

Child, Concluding Observations on Singapore,

CRC/C/15/Add.220, 27 October 2003.

United Nations Committee for the Rights of the

Child, General Comment No. 10, CRC/C/

GC/10, 25 April 2007.

United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons

with Disabilities (2006).

United Nations Rules for the Treatment of Women

Prisoners and Non-custodial Measures for

Women (2010).

United Nations Sub-Committee on the Prevention

of Torture, Ninth annual report of the SPT,

CAT/C/57/4, 22 March 2016.

Volkart, R., Rothenfluh, T., Kobelt, W., Dittrich,

A., & Ernst, K. (1983). Solitary confinement

as risk factor for psychiatric hospitalization (in

German). Psychiatr Clin (Basel), 16(5-6): pp.

-77.

Wildeman, C. & Andersen, L.H. (2020). Solitary

placement and post-release mortality risk among

formerly incarcerated individuals: A populationbased

study. Lancet Public Health 5(2): e107-e113.

doi: 10.1016/S2468-2667(19)30271-3.

World Medical Association, (2019). Statement on

Solitary Confinement, adopted by the 65th

WMA General Assembly, Durban, South Africa,

October 2014 and revised by the 70th WMA

General Assembly, Tbilisi, Georgia, October

Published

2023-03-17

How to Cite

Brasholt, M., Sveaass, N., Pérez Sales, P., Marboeuf, H., Cakal, E., & Søndergaard, E. (2023). Protocol on medico-legal documentation of solitary confinement. Torture Journal, 33(1), 92–118. https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v33i1.130739

Issue

Section

Special section: forensic documentation of psychological torture