A Qualitative Meta-Study of a Decade of the Holistic Ecological Approach to Talent Development
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7146/sjsep.v3i.128317Keywords:
sports psychology, talent development environments, organisational psychology, re-search rigour, meta-synthesisAbstract
The Holistic-Ecological Approach (HEA) was introduced in 2010, and it is now important to provide a critical review after a decade of research elaborating on the framework. The purpose of this study was to critically assess the methodological and theoretical trends in research using the HEA in the study of athletic talent development environments (ATDE). We used a qualitative meta-study to review twelve studies published from 2010 to the first quarter of 2021. Our meta-theory analysis found that future studies should consider the use of Bronfenbrenner’s work on development and address previous critiques on its use since it can limit the potential of the HEA re-search. In the meta-methods, we found that all studies used multiple and varied data collection strategies (e.g., interviews, observations, organisational documents). We also found a high degree of transparency and rigour exemplified by using multiple validity strategies. Method weaknesses were an underrepresentation of neutral or negative cases. The meta-data analysis showed that most ATDEs were classified as successful or unsuccessful ahead of data collection, suggesting potential confirmation bias. We also found that all ATDEs had competing findings, which suggests a need for exploring negative or ambiguous findings. Future research could benefit from clarifying the use of underlying theoretical assumptions; contrasting findings with neutral cases, outliers, and negative cases to clarify the definition of successful ATDEs; and expanding on the methodological approach.
References
Aalberg, R. R., & Sæther, S. A. (2016). The Talent Development Environment in a Norwegian top-level football club. Sport Science Review, 25(3–4), 159–182. https://doi.org/10.1515/ssr-2016-0009
Agergaard, S., & Sørensen, J. K. (2010). Policy, sport and integration: The case of talented ethnic minority players in danish football clubs. International Journal of Sport Policy, 2(2), 205–221. https://doi.org/10.1080/19406940.2010.488067
Alvesson, M. (2017). Studying Culture in Organizations: Not taking for granted the taken-for-granted. In A. Wilkinson, S. J. Armstrong, & M. Lounsbury (Eds.), The Oxford Book of Management (pp. 103–126). Oxford University Press.
Araújo, D., & Davids, K. (2009). Ecological approaches to cognition and action in sport: Ask not what you do, but where you do it. Journal of Sport Psychology, 40(March), 5–37.
Araújo, D., Davids, K., Hammond, K. R., Bateman, R. a, Kaminski, G., Krebs, R. J., & Abernethy, B. (2009). Ecological Approaches to cognition and exercise. International Journal of Sport Psychology, 40(March), 5–37.
Bagnoli, A. (2009). Beyond the standard interview: the use of graphic elicitation and arts-based methods. Qualitative Research, 9(5), 547–570. https://doi.org/10.1177/1468794109343625
Balish, S., & Côté, J. (2014). The influence of community on athletic development: an integrated case study. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 6(1), 98–120. https://doi.org/10.1080/2159676X.2013.766815
Bergeron, M. F., Mountjoy, M., Armstrong, N., Chia, M., Côté, J., Emery, C. a., Faigenbaum, A., Hall, G., Kriemler, S., Léglise, M., Malina, R. M., Pensgaard, A. M., Sanchez, A., Soligard, T., Sundgot-Borgen, J., van Mechelen, W., Weissensteiner, J. R., & Engebretsen, L. (2015). International Olympic Committee consensus statement on youth athletic development. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 49(13), 843–851. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2015-094962
Bloom, B. S. (1985). Developing talent in young people. Ballantine.
Booth, A., Papaioannou, D., & Sutton, A. (2012). Systematic Approches to a Successful Literature Review (1st ed.). SAGE Publications Inc.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1979). The ecology of human development. Harvard University Press.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1994). Ecological Models of Human Development. In International Encyclopedia of Education, Vol. 3 (2nd ed., pp. 1643–1647). Elsevier.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (1999). Environments in developmental perspective. In S. L. Friedman & T. D. Wachs (Eds.), Measuring environment across the life span: Emerging methods and concepts (pp. 3–28). American Psychological Association Press.
Bronfenbrenner, U. (2005). Making human beings human: Bioecological perspectives on human development.
Chamberlain, K. (2011). Do you really need a methodology? QMiP Bulleting, 13, 59–63.
Collins, C. S., & Stockton, C. M. (2018). The Central Role of Theory in Qualitative Research. International Journal of Qualitative Methods, 17(1), 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406918797475
Costa, A. L., & Kallick, B. (1993). Through the Lens of a Critical Friend. Educational Leadership, 51, 49–51.
Costantino, T. E. (2008). Constructivism. In L. M. Given (Ed.), The SAGE Encyclopedia of Qualitative Research Methods (pp. 116–121). SAGE Publications, Inc. https://doi.org/10.4135/9781412963909.n64
Côté, J. (1999). The influence of the family in the development of talent in sport. The Sport Psychologist, 13, 395–417. https://doi.org/10.1177/1527002502003003001
Critical Appraisal Skills Programme. (2013). CASP Qualitative Checklist.
Culver, D. M. (2012). Qualitative Research in Sport Psychology Journals: The Next Decade 2000-2009 and Beyond. Sport Psychologist, 26(2), 261–281.
Culver, D. M., Gilbert, W., & Sparkes, A. (2012). Qualitative research in sport psychology journals: The next decade 2000-2009 and beyond. Sport Psychologist, 26(2), 261–281. https://doi.org/10.1123/tsp.26.2.261
Davids, K., Gullich, A., Shuttleworth, R., & Araújo, D. (2017). Understanding environmental and task constraints on talent development: Analysis of micro-structure of practice and macro-structure of development histories. In J. Baker, S. Cobley, J. Schorer, & N. Wattie (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Talent Identification and Development in Sport. Routledge.
Diment, G., Henriksen, K., & Larsen, C. H. (2020). Team Denmark’s Sport Psychology Professional Philosophy 2.0. Scandinavian Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2, 26–32. https://doi.org/10.7146/sjsep.v2i0.115660
Edmondson, A. (1999). Psychological safety and learning behavior in work teams. Administrative Science Quarterly, 44(2), 350–383. https://doi.org/10.2307/2666999
Flatgård, G., Larsen, C. H., & Sæther, S. A. (2020). Talent development environment in a professional football club in Norway. Scandinavian Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2, 8–15. https://doi.org/10.7146/sjsep.v2i0.114470
Fraser, K. D., & Al Sayah, F. (2011). Arts-based methods in health research: A systematic review of the literature. https://doi.org/10.1080/17533015.2011.561357
Gagné, F. (2011). Academic talent development and the equity issue in gifted education. Talent Development & Excellence, 3, 3–22.
Gagné, F. (2013). The DMGT: Changes Within, Beneath, and Beyond. Talent Development and Excellence, 5(1), 5–19.
Gibson, L., & Groom, R. (2018). Ambiguity, manageability and the orchestration of organisational change: a case study of an English Premier League Academy Manager. Sports Coaching Review, 7(1), 23–44. https://doi.org/10.1080/21640629.2017.1317173
Haukli, J. S., Larsen, C. H., Feddersen, N. B., & Sæther, S. A. (2021). The athlete talent development environment in the best ranked football academy in Norwegian football: The case of the U16 team in Stabæk football club. Current Issues in Sport Science. https://doi.org/10.36950/2021ciss008
Henriksen, K. (2010). The Ecology of Talent Development in Sport. In PhD Thesis. University of Southern Denmark.
Henriksen, K., Larsen, C. H., & Christensen, M. K. (2014). Looking at success from its opposite pole: The case of a talent development golf environment in Denmark. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 12(2), 134–149. https://doi.org/10.1080/1612197X.2013.853473
Henriksen, K., Schinke, R., Moesch, K., McCann, S., Parham, W. D., Larsen, C. H., & Terry, P. (2019). Consensus statement on improving the mental health of high performance athletes. International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1–8. https://doi.org/10.1080/1612197X.2019.1570473
Henriksen, K., & Stambulova, N. (2017). Creating Optimal Environments for Talent Development - A Holistic Ecological Approach. In J. Baker, S. Cobley, J. Schorer, & N. Wattie (Eds.), Routledge Handbook of Talent Identification and Development in Sport (pp. 271–284). Routledge.
Henriksen, K., Stambulova, N., & Roessler, K. K. (2010a). Holistic approach to athletic talent development environments: A successful sailing milieu. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 11(3), 212–222. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2009.10.005
Henriksen, K., Stambulova, N., & Roessler, K. K. (2010b). Successful talent development in track and field: Considering the role of environment. Scandinavian Journal of Medicine and Science in Sports, 20(SUPPL. 2), 122–132. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0838.2010.01187.x
Henriksen, K., Stambulova, N., & Roessler, K. K. (2011). Riding the Wave of an Expert : A Successful Talent Development Environment in Kayaking. The Sport Psychologist, 25, 341–362.
Henriksen, K., Storm, L. K., Kuettel, A., Linnér, L., & Stambulova, N. (2020). A holistic ecological approach to sport and study: The case of an athlete friendly university in Denmark. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 47. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2019.101637
Holt, N. L., Neely, K. C., Slater, L. G., Camiré, M., Côté, J., Fraser-Thomas, J., Macdonald, D., Strachan, L., & Tamminen, K. A. (2017). A grounded theory of positive youth development through sport based on results from a qualitative meta-study. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 10(1), 1–49. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2016.1180704
Kammeradvokaten. (2020). Undersøgelse af forholdene for elitesvømmere i Dansk Svømmeunion.
Krebs, R. J. (2009). Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Theory of Human Development and the process of development of sports talent. International Journal of Sport Ps, 40(1), 108–135. www.ijsp-online.com
Larsen, C. H., Alfermann, D., Henriksen, K., & Christensen, M. K. (2013). Successful talent development in soccer: The characteristics of the environment. Sport, Exercise, and Performance Psychology, 2(3), 190–206. https://doi.org/10.1037/a0031958
Larsen, C. H., Storm, L. K., Sæther, S. A., Pyrdol, N., & Henriksen, K. (2020). A world class academy in professional football: The case of Ajax Amsterdam. Scandinavian Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 2, 33–43. https://doi.org/10.7146/sjsep.v2i0.119746
Levitt, H. M., Bamberg, M., Creswell, J. W., Frost, D. M., Josselson, R., & Suárez-Orozco, C. (2018). Journal article reporting standards for qualitative primary, qualitative meta-analytic, and mixed methods research in psychology: The APA publications and communications board task force report. American Psychologist, 73(1), 26–46. https://doi.org/10.1037/amp0000151
Lewis, J., Ritchie, J., Ormston, R., & Morrell, G. (2014). Generalising from Qualitative Research. In J. Ritchie, J. Lewis, C. McNaughton Nicholls, & R. Ormston (Eds.), Qualitative Research Practice: a guide for social science students and researchers (2nd Editio). SAGE Publications Inc.
Li, C., Wang, C. K. J., & Pyun, D. Y. (2014). Talent Development Environmental Factors in Sport: A Review and Taxonomic Classification. Quest, 66(4), 433–447. https://doi.org/10.1080/00336297.2014.944715
Maitland, A., Hills, L. A., & Rhind, D. J. (2015). Organisational culture in sport - A systematic review. Sport Management Review, 18(4), 501–516. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.smr.2014.11.004
Mannion, R., & Davies, H. (2016). Culture in Health Care Organizations. In E. Ferlie, K. Montgomery, & A. R. Pedersen (Eds.), The Oxford Handbook of Health Care Management (First Edit, pp. 98–116). Oxford University Press. https://doi.org/10.1093/oxfordhb/9780198705109.001.0001
Martindale, R. J. J. (2005). Talent Development: A Guide for Practice and Research Within Sport. Quest, 57(4), 353–375. https://doi.org/10.1080/00336297.2005.10491862
Mathorne, O. W., Henriksen, K., & Stambulova, N. (2020). An “Organizational Triangle” to Coordinate Talent Development: A Case Study in Danish Swimming. Case Studies in Sport and Exercise Psychology, 4(1), 11–20. https://doi.org/10.1123/cssep.2019-0017
May, R. (1983). The discovery of being: Writings in existential psychotherapy.
McDougall, M., Ronkainen, N., Richardson, D., Littlewood, M., & Nesti, M. (2019). Three team and organisational culture myths and their consequences for sport psychology research and practice. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 1–16. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984x.2019.1638433
McDougall, M., Ronkainen, N., Richardson, D., Littlewood, M., & Nesti, M. (2020). Organizational Culture Beyond Consensus and Clarity: Narratives From Elite Sport. The Sport Psychologist, 34(4), 288–299. https://doi.org/10.1123/tsp.2019-0163
Meyerson, D., & Martin, J. (1987). Cultural Change: An Integration of Three Different Views. Journal of Management Studies, 24(6), 623–647.
Mountjoy, M. (2019). ‘Only by speaking out can we create lasting change’: what can we learn from the Dr Larry Nassar tragedy? British Journal of Sports Medicine, 53(1), 57–60. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2018-099403
Paterson, B. L., Thorne, S. E., Canam, C., & Jillings, C. (2001). Meta-Study of Qualitative Health Research - A Practical Guide to Meta-Analysis and Meta-Synthesis (1st ed.). SAGE Publications Inc.
Patton, W., & McMahon, M. (2014). Career development and systems theory: Connecting theory and practice (3rd ed.). Sense Publishers. https://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=k_QkBAAAQBAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PR5&dq=Patton,+W.,+%26+McMahon,+M.+(2006).+Career+development+and+systems+theory:+Connecting+theory+and+practice.+Rotterdam:+Sense+Publishers.&ots=lLLS-OrSWR&sig=Ja8KrHfpkrEbyEeRzErQoEQ7dg
Ray, C. A. (1986). CORPORATE CULTURE: THE LAST FRONTIER OF CONTROL? Journal of Management Studies, 23(3), 287–297. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1467-6486.1986.tb00955.x
Rees, T., Hardy, L., Güllich, A., Abernethy, B., Côté, J., Woodman, T., Montgomery, H., Laing, S., & Warr, C. (2016). The Great British Medalists Project: A Review of Current Knowledge on the Development of the World’s Best Sporting Talent. Sports Medicine, 46(8), 1041–1058. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40279-016-0476-2
Reeves, M. J., & Roberts, S. J. (2020). A bioecological perspective on talent identification in junior-elite soccer: A Pan-European perspective. Journal of Sports Sciences, 38(11–12), 1259–1268. https://doi.org/10.1080/02640414.2019.1702282
Relvas, H., Littlewood, M., Nesti, M., Gilbourne, D., & Richardson, D. (2010). Organizational Structures and Working Practices in Elite European Professional Football Clubs: Understanding the Relationship between Youth and Professional Domains. European Sport Management Quarterly, 10(2), 165–187. https://doi.org/10.1080/16184740903559891
Richert, A. (2010). Integrating existential and narrative therapy: A theoretical base for eclectic practice. http://psycnet.apa.org/record/2010-20578-000
Ronkainen, N. J., Kavoura, A., & Ryba, T. V. (2015). A meta-study of athletic identity research in sport psychology: Current status and future directions. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 9(1), 45–64. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2015.1096414
Ronkainen, N. J., Kavoura, A., & Ryba, T. V. (2016). Narrative and discursive perspectives on athletic identity: Past, present, and future. Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 27, 128–137. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.psychsport.2016.08.010
Ryom, K., Ravn, M., Düring, R., & Henriksen, K. (2020). Talent Development in Football—A Holistic Perspective: The Case of KRC Genk. International Sport Coaching Journal, 7(3), 360–369. https://doi.org/10.1123/iscj.2019-0045
Schein, E. H. (1990). Organizational culture. American Psychologist, 45, 109–119. https://doi.org/10.1037/0003-066X.45.2.109
Schein, E. H. (2010). Organizational Culture and Leadership (4th ed.). Jossey-Bass Business and Management.
Seanor, M., Schinke, R. J., Stambulova, N. B., Ross, D., & Kpazai, G. (2017). Cultivating Olympic champions: A trampoline development environment from grass roots to podium. Journal of Sport Psychology in Action, 8(2), 96–108. https://doi.org/10.1080/21520704.2017.1327908
Smith, B., & McGannon, K. R. (2018). Developing rigor in qualitative research: problems and opportunities within sport and exercise psychology. International Review of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 11(1), 101–121. https://doi.org/10.1080/1750984X.2017.1317357
Sport England. (2018). The Talent Plan: Creating the world’s best talent system.
Thames Valley & Wessex Healthcare Librarians. (2016). The Literature Search Process: Guidance for NHS Researchers.
Tudge, J. R. H., Mokrova, I., Hatfield, B. E., & Karnik, R. B. (2009). Uses and Misuses of Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Theory of Human Development. Journal of Family Theory & Review, 1, 198–210. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1111/j.1756-2589.2009.00026.x
Tudge, J. R. H., Payir, A., Merçon-Vargas, E., Cao, H., Liang, Y., Li, J., & O’Brien, L. (2016). Still Misused After All These Years? A Reevaluation of the Uses of Bronfenbrenner’s Bioecological Theory of Human Development. Journal of Family Theory & Review, 8(4), 427–445. https://doi.org/10.1111/jftr.12165
Wagstaff, C. R. D., & Burton-Wylie, S. (2018). Organisational culture in sport: A conceptual, definitional and methodological review. Sport & Exercise Psychology Review, 14(2), 32–52.
Wagstaff, C. R. D., Fletcher, D., & Hanton, S. (2012). Positive Organizational Psychology in Sport: An Ethnography of Organizational Functioning in a National Sport Organization. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 24(1), 26–47. https://doi.org/10.1080/10413200.2011.589423
Walsh, D., & Downe, S. (2005). Meta-synthesis method for qualitative research: A literature review. Methodological Issues in Nursing Research, 50(2). https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1365-2648.2005.03380.x
Wenger, E. (1998). Communities of practice. Learning, meaning, and identity. Cambridge University Press.
Whitley, M. A., & Massey, W. V. (2018). Navigating tensions in qualitative research methodology geography personality and beyond. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health, 1–12. https://doi.org/doi.org/10.1080/2159676X.2018.1470559
