The effectiveness of psychoanalytic psychotherapy in individuals diagnosed with PTSD due to torture and severe human right violations
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.7146/torture.v33i1.132231Keywords:
torture, PTSD, post-traumatic stress disorder, psychotherapy, psychoanalytic therapy, effectivenessAbstract
Abstract
Introduction: Various psychotherapies have been applied to individuals who have been subjected to torture and severe human rights and to patients with PTSD, however, studies assessing the effectiveness of such therapies are limited. Psychoanalytic psychotherapy is said to be used frequently in practice for these patient groups. Yet, there are scarcely any studies assessing its efficacy. In this study, we aim to assess the effectiveness of psychoanalytic psychotherapy in patients with PTSD associated with torture and severe human rights violations. Additionally, the study seeks to monitor the continuity of therapy within the first year and its relationship with overall clinical change.
Methods: 70 patients with PTSD related to torture and severe human rights violations who applied to the Human Rights Foundation of Turkey were given psychoanalytic psychotherapy. CGI-S and CGI-I scales were applied to the patients (in Months 1, 3, 6, 9, and 12); and the patients' continuity of therapy and the changes in their recovery during the one-year psychotherapy period were assessed.
Results: 38 (54.3%) of the patients were female. Their mean age was 37.7 years (SD = 12.25), while their mean baseline CGI-S score was 4.67. The mean length of treatment was 21.9 sessions (SD = 20.30). As the number of sessions increased, the final CGI-I scores of the patients improved significantly (p <.001) towards recovery. The change towards recovery became more evident particularly in the patients who had continued the therapy for more than 12 sessions. Mean scores for CGI-I scale were 3.46, 2.95, 2.23, 2.00, and 1.54 for months 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12 respectively. In addition, the drop-out rate was 34% (24 patients) for those who dropped out of therapy prematurely without any CGI-I assessment (9 patients) and those who dropped out of therapy with no improvement in their CGI-I scores –i.e. with CGI-I scores of 4-7 (15 patients).
Conclusions: Considering the limited literature in the field, this study has provided significant data on the effectiveness of the use of psychoanalytic psychotherapy in individuals diagnosed with PTSD related to torture and severe human rights violations, despite its limitations –including not involving a control group. Furthermore, the findings might offer important clues regarding the relationship between continuity of therapy and clinical change.
References
American Psychiatric Association. (1994). Diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (4th ed.). Washington, DC: Author.
Amnesty International, 2014 Amnesty International. Torture in 2014: 30 years of broken promises. Amnesty International. 2014. http://www.amnesty.org/en/library/info/ACT40/004/2014/en. [cited 21 June 2019].
Baekeland F, & Lundwall L. (1975). Dropping out of treatment: A critical review. Psychological Bulletin 1975, 82(5), 738-783.
Basoglu M. (1993). Prevention of torture and care of survivors. An integrated approach. JAMA: Journal of the American Medical Association, 279(5), 606-11.
Basoglu M, Ekblad S, Bäärnhielm S, Livanou M. (2004). Cognitive-behavioral treatment of tortured asylum seekers: a case study. Journal of Anxiety Disorder, 18(3), 357-69.
Brom, D., Kleber, R. J., & Defares, P. B. (1989). Brief Psychotherapy for Posttraumatic Stress Disorders. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 57(5), 607-612.
Busner, J., & Targum, S. (2007, July). The Clinical Global Impressions Scale: Applying a Research Tool in Clinical Practice. Psychiatry, 4(7), 28-37.
Durham, R. C., Chambers, J. A., Power, K. G., Sharp, D. M., Macdonald, R. R., Major, K. A., Dow, M. G. T., Gumley, A. I. (2005). Long-term outcome of cognitive behaviour therapy clinical trials in central Scotland. Health Technology Assessment, 9(42), 1-4.
Fonagy, P. (2015). The effectiveness of psychodynamic psychotherapies: an update. World Psychiatry, 14 (2): 137-150.
Garfield SL. (1994). Research on client variables in psychotherapy. In A. E. Bergin & S. L. Garfield (Eds.), Handbook of psychotherapy and behavior change (p.190-228). New York: Wiley.
Grodin M, Tarantola D, Annas G, Gruskin S, editors. (2013). Health and Human Rights in a Changing World. Taylor & Francis.
Guy, W. (1976). ECDEU assessment manual for psychopharmacology. US Department of Health, Education, and Welfare, Public Health Service, Alcohol, Drug Abuse, and Mental Health Administration, National Institute of Mental Health, Psychopharmacology Research Branch, Division of Extramural Research Programs. 218-22.
Hamid A, Patel N, Williams A.C.D.C (2019) Psychological, social, and welfare interventions for torture survivors: A systematic review and meta- analysis of randomised controlled trials. PLoS Med 16(9): e1002919. [https://doi.org/10.1371/journal. pmed.1002919.]
Holmqvist, R., Andersen, K., Anjum, T., & Alinder, B. (2006). Change in Self-Image and PTSD Symptoms in Short-Term Therapies with Traumatized Refugees. Psychoanalytic Psychotherapy, 20(4), 251-265.
Holtz T.H. (1998). Refugee trauma versus torture trauma: a retrospective controlled cohort study of Tibetan refugees. Journal of Nervous & Mental Disease, 186(1), 24-34.
Human Rights Foundation of Turkey (HRFT) (1994). Annual Report. File of torture: Deaths in detention places or prisons, 12 September 1980-12 September 1994. Human Rights Foundation of Turkey Publications, Ankara. (http://en.tihv.org.tr/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/Ra1994HumanRigthsReport.pdf)
Human Rights Watch (2005). Still critical.Prospects in 2005 for Internally Displaced Kurds in Turkey. (https://www.hrw.org/reports/2005/turkey0305/turkey0305.pdf)
İstanbul Protokolü. (2003) [2017]. İşkence ve Diğer Zalimane, İnsanlık Dışı, Aşağılayıcı Muamele veya Cezaların Etkili Biçimde Soruşturulması ve Belgelendirilmesi İçin El Kılavuzu. Ankara: Türkiye İnsan Hakları Vakfı Yayınları.
Jaranson J.M., Butcher J., Halcon, L., Johnson, D.R., Robertson, C., Savik, K., Spring, M., Westermever, J. (2004) Somali and Oromo refugees: correlates of torture and trauma history. Am J Public Health, 94(4), 591-8.
Jaranson J.M. & Quiroga J. (2011). Evaluating the services of torture rehabilitation programmes. Torture, 21(2), 98–140.
Kessler L.G., Steinwachs D.M., Hankin J.R. (1990). Episodes of psychiatric utilization. Medical Care, 18, 1219-1227.
Khazaie H., Rezaie L., de Jong D.M. (2013). Dropping out of outpatient psychiatric treatment: a preliminary report of a 2-year follow-up of 1500 psychiatric outpatients in Kermanshah, Iran. General Hospital Psychiatry, Vol. 35 (3), 314-9.
Kline, A. C., Cooper, A. A., Rytwinksi, N. K., & Feeny, N. C. (2018). Long-term efficacy of psychotherapy for posttraumatic stress disorder: A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Clinical psychology review, 59, 30-40.
Leichsenring F. (2005). Are psychodynamic and psychoanalytic therapies effective?: A review of empirical data. The International journal of Psychoanalysis, 86(3), 841–868.
Leichsenring, F., Klein, S., & Salzer, S. (2014). The efficacy of psychodynamic psychotherapy in specific mental disorders: a 2013 update of empirical evidence. Contemporary Psychoanalysis, 50(1-2), 89-130.
Levi, O., Bar-Haim, Y., & Fruchter, E. (2015). Cognitive-Behavioural Therapy and Psychodynamic Psychotherapy in the Treatment of Combat-Related Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder: A Comparative Effectiveness Study. Clinical Psychology and Psychotherapy 23, 298-307.
McFarlane, C. A., & Kaplan, I. (2012). Evidence-based psychological interventions for adult survivors of torture and trauma: a 30-year review. Transcultural psychiatry, 49(3-4), 539-567.
McMurran M., Huband N., Overton, E. (2010) Non-completion of personality disorder treatments: A systematic review of correlates, con- sequences, and interventions. Clinical Psychology Review, 30, 277–287.
Nicholson B.L., Kay, D.M. (1999). Group treatment of traumatized Cambodian women: a culture-specific approach. Social Work, 44(5):470-9.
Olfson, M., Mojtabai, R., Sampson, N. A., Hwang, I., Druss, B., Wang, P. S., & Kessler, R. C. (2009). Dropout from outpatient mental health care in the United States. Psychiatric Services, 60(7), 898-907.
Pallant, J. (2016). SPSS kullanma kılavuzu: SPSS ile adım adım veri analizi (S. Balcı ve B. Ahi, Çev.) [SPSS survival manual: A step by step guide to data analysis using IBM SPSS]. Ankara: Anı Yayıncılık.
Paintain, E., Cassidy, S. (2018) First-line Therapy for Post-traumatic Stress Disorder: A Systematic Review of Cognitive Bahavioural Therapy and Psychodynamic Approaches. Counselling and Psychotherapy Research, 18(3), 237-250.
Patel N, Granville-Chapman C. (2010). Health Assessments with Survivors of Torture: Good Practice Clinical Guidelines. Joint publication of Medical Foundation, London and Department of Health, United Kingdom.
Patel N, Williams A. C. D. C., Kellezi, B. (2016) Reviewing outcomes of psychological interventions with torture survivors: Conceptual, methodological and ethical Issues. Torture, 26(1): 2-16.
Piper, W. E., Ogrodniczuk, J. S., Joyce, A. S., McCallum, M., Rosie, J. S., O'kelly, J. G., & Steinberg, P. I. (1999). Prediction of dropping out in time-limited, interpretive individual psychotherapy. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training, 36(2), 114.
Refugee Health Care Center (1988). Annual report. Rijswijk, Netherlands: Ministery of Welfare, Health and Cultura Affairs.
Reis B. F., Brown L. G. (1999). Reducing psychotherapy dropouts: Maximizing perspective convergence in the psychotherapy dyad. Psychotherapy: Theory, Research, Practice, Training, 36(2), p.123-136.
Rosenbaum R, Hoyt MF, Talmon M. (1989). The challenge of single-session therapies: Creating pivotal moments. In R. Wells & V. Giantelli (Eds.), The handbook of brief therapies (p.165-189). New York: Plenum.
Sadock, B. J., Sadock, V. A., & Ruiz, P. (2016). Kaplan&Sadock Psikiyatri Davranış Bilimleri/Klinik Psikiyatri. (Onbirinci Baskı) A. Bozkurt (Çev. Ed.) Ankara: Güneş Tıp Kitabevleri.
Schauer, M., Neuner, F., & Elbert, T. (2011). Narrative exposure therapy: A short term treatment for traumatic stress disorders (2nd Rev. ed.). Cambridge, MA: Hogrefe & Huber.
Schottenbauer, M. A., Glass, C. R., Arnkoff, D. B., Tendick, V., & Gray, S. H. (2008). Nonresponse and dropout rates in outcome studies on PTSD: Review and methodological considerations. Psychiatry: Interpersonal and biological processes, 71(2), 134-168.
Song, S. J., Subica, A., Kaplan, C., Tol, W., & De Jong, J. (2018). Predicting the mental health and functioning of torture survivors. The Journal of nervous and mental disease, 206(1), 33-39.
Spearing, M. K., Post, R. K., Leverich, G. S., Brant D., &Nolen W. (1997) Modification of the Clinical Global Impressions (CGI) scal for use in bipolar illness (BP): the CGI-BP. Psychiatry Research, 73(3), 159-71.
Steel, Z., Chey, T., Silove, D., Marnane, C., Bryant, R. A., van Ommeran, M. (2009). Association of torture and other potentially traumatic events with mental health outcomes among populations exposed to mass conflict and displacement: A systematic review and meta-analysis. JAMA, 302(5), 537-549.
Swift, J. K., Greenberg, R. P. (2012). Premature Discontinuation in Adult Psychotherapy: A Meta-Analysis. Journal of Consulting and Clinical Psychology, 80(4), 547–559.
Thormählen, B., Weinryb, R. M., Norén, K., Vinnars, B., Bågedahl-Strindlund, M. (2003). Patient Factors Predicting Dropout from Supportive-Expressive Psychotherapy for Patients with Personality Disorders. Psychotherapy Research, 13(4), 493-509.
United Nations General Assembly. Convention against torture and other cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment. Constitution. 1984 Dec; 5(7):5.
Vrana, S. R., Campbell, T. A., Clay, R. (2013). Survey of national consortium of torture treatment program therapists about the assessment, diagnosis, and treatment of the psychological sequelae of torture. Traumatology, 19(2):144-53.
Wang, J. (2007). Mental health treatment dropout and its correlates in a general population sample. Medical Care 45, 224-229.
Weiss, W. M., Ugueto, A. M., Mahmooth, Z., Murray, L. K., Hall, B. J., Nadison, M., Rasmussen, A., Lee, J. S., Vazzano, A., Bass, J., Bolton, P. (2016). Mental health interventions and priorities for research for adult survivors of torture and systematic violence: a review of the literature. Torture, 26(1):17-44.
Wierzbicki, M., Pekarik, G. (1993). A meta-analysis of psychotherapy dropout. Professional Psychology: Research and Practice, 24(2), 190-195.
Yılmaz, D., Özyıldırım, İ., Ünüvar, Ü., Kutlu, L., Fincancı, Ş. K. (2015). Türkiye’de işkencenin 22 yılı: TİHV Tedavi ve Rehabilitasyon Merkezleri 1991-2012 yılları arasındaki başvuruların değerlendirilmesi. Ankara: TİHV Yayınları.
Downloads
Published
How to Cite
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2023 Torture Journal
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
We accept that some authors (e.g. government employees in some countries) are unable to transfer copyright. The Creative Commons Licence Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0) covers both the Torture Journal and the IRCT web site. The publisher will not put any limitation on the personal freedom of the author to use material contained in the paper in other works which may be published, provided that acknowledgement is made to the original place of publication.
