Syddør, norddør og det kønsopdelte kirkerum
Resumé
South door, north door, and the gender separated church interior
By Martin Wangsgaard Jürgensen
Almost every Romanesque church built in medieval Denmark was constructed with two doorways, one on the north side of the nave and one on the southern side. These doors have traditionally been interpreted as being used by men and women respectively. The men would have used the southern door while the north door was reserved to the women. This explanation has more or less been accepted in most of the Danish literature on the medieval churches, but a closer scrutiny of the evidence for this interpretation reveals it as highly unlikely. Instead of the old gender related explanation this article aims at interpreting the doorways of the Romanesque churches in the light of the liturgical movements of the 10th and 11th centuries. It is proposed here that only one of the church doors was used as a regular entryway while the other one was used in connection with the rituals of public penance, excommunication, the churching of women and burial rites. On the other hand the article argues that gender separation was widely used inside of the churches through the early and high middle ages. This practice waned during the 15th century but was taken up again by the Protestant reformers and reintroduced in the parish churches. The main point is that gender separation and the two doorways of the church had nothing to do with each other. The oldest written sources explaining the doorways as male and female entryways are from the later part of the 19th century and are very much rooted in a romantic or nostalgic understanding of the medieval church.
Referencer
Ahrens, Claus: Die frühen Holzkirchen Europas I-II, Stuttgart 2001.
Andås, Margrete Syrstad: Art and Ritual in the Liminal Zone, The Medieval Cathedral of Trondheim (ed. Margrete Syrstad Andås m.fl.), Turnhout 2007, s. 47-126.
Archer, Léonie J.: The Role of Jewish Women in the Religion, Ritual and Cult of Graeco-Roman Palestine, Images of Women in Antiquity, rev. ed., London 1993, s. 273-287.
Augustin: Om Guds Stad (oversat af Bent Dalsgaard Larsen), Århus 2002.
Augustinus, Aurelius: Der Gottesstaat / De Civitate Dei bd. I (oversat af Carl Johann Perl), München/Wien/Zürich 1979.
Beinert, Wolfgang: Die Kirche - Gottes Heil in der Welt. Die Lehre von der Kirche nach Schriften des Rupert von Deutz, Honorius Augustodunensis und Gerhoch von Reichersberg. Ein Beitrag zur Ekklesiologie des 12. Jahrhunderts, Beiträge zur Geschichte der Philosophie und Theologie des Mittelalters, Neu Folge, bd. 13, Münster 1973.
Bibelen (ved Det Danske Bibelselskab), København 1992.
Chastel, André: Italian Art, 2. ed., London 1972.
Cogelerus, Johannes: Imagines elegantissimae: quae multum lucis ad intelligendos doctrinae Christianae locos adferre possunt, Collectae, partim ex praelectionibus Domini Philippi Melanthonis, partim ex scriptis Patrum a Iohanne Cogelero, Verbi diuini ministro Stetini cum praefatione D. Georgij Maioris, Wittenberg 1558.
Conant, Kenneth John: Carolingian and Romanesque Architecture 800-1200, 4th ed. 2nd printing, Yale University Press 1993.
Constitutions of the Holy Fathers vol. 7 (oversat af James Donaldson), The Ante-Nicene Fathers. Translations of the Fathers down to A.D. 325, reprinted ed., Grand Rapids 1982.
Danmarks Kirker, København 1933ff.
Durandus, William: The Symbolism of Churches and Church Ornaments (oversat af John Mason Neale & Benjamin Webb), 3. ed., London 1906.
Duranti, Guillelmi: Rationale Divinorum Offiorum (ed. A. Davril & T. M. Thibodeau) bd. 1, Turnhout 1995.
French, Kathrine L.: The Seat under Our Lady: Gender and Seating in Late Medieval English Parish Churches, Women’s Space. Patronage, Place, and Gender in the Medieval Church (ed. Virginia Chieffo Raguin & Sarah Stanbury), New York 2005, s. 141-160.
Gem, Richard: A Recession in English Architecture during the Early Eleventh Century, and Its Effect on the Development of the Romanesque Style, The Journal of the British Archaeological Association, 3rd series, 38, 1975, s. 28-49.
Gem, Richard: Tenth-Century Architecture in England, Il secolo di ferro: mito e realtà del secolo X. Settimane di studio del centro italiano di studi sull’alto medioevo 38 1991, s. 803-836.
Gittos, Helen: Architecture and Liturgy in England c. 1000: Problems and Possibilities, The White Mantle of Churches. Architecture, Liturgy, and Art Around the Millenium (ed. Nigel Hiscock), Turnhout 2003, s. 91-106.
Gotfredsen, Lise & Hans Jørgen Frederiksen: Troens Billeder. Romansk kunst i Danmark, 2. udg. 2003.
Heldvad, Niels: Amphitheatrum fidei catholicæ et ceremoniarum ecclesiæ Jesu Christi. D. i. Ein herrlich, aussbündig Schawplahn, der heiligen, christlichen, apostolischen vnd catholischen Kirchen, zu allen Zeiten, Hamburg 1622.
Hobbes, Thomas: Leviathan (ed. G. A. J. Rogers & K. Schuhmann), Bristol 2003.
Hostetler, John A.: Hutterite Society, Baltimore/London 1974.
Johannsen, Hugo & Claus M. Smidt: Danmarks Arkitektur: Kirkens huse, København 1981.
Jungmann, Josef Andreas: Die lateinischen Bußriten in ihrer geschichtlichen Entwicklung, Innsbruck 1932.
Jungmann, Josef Andreas: Missarum Sollemnia. Eine genetische Erklärung der Römische Messe I-II, 4. Ausg., 1958.
Karant-Nunn, Susan: The Reformation of Ritual. An interpretation of early modern Germany, ny udgave, New York 2007.
Kendall, Calvin B.: The Allegory of the Church. Romanesque Portals and Their Verse Inscriptions, Toronto/Buffalo/London 1998.
Kieffer-Olsen, Jakob: Grav og gravskik - 8 kirkegårdsudgravninger, Højbjerg 1993.
Kirkeordinansen 1537/39 (udg. Martin Schwartz Lausten), København 1989.
Kolderup-Rosenvinge, J. L. A.: Samling af gamle danske Love 1-5, 1821-46.
Krautheimer, Richard: The Carolingian Revival of Early Christian Architecture, The Art Bulletin vol. 24 nr. 1 1942, s. 1-38.
Krautheimer, Richard: Early Christian and Byzantine Architecture, London 1965.
Krüger, Kristina: Monastic Costums and Liturgy in the Light of Architectural Evidence: A Case Study on Processions (Eleventh- Twelfth Centuries), From Dead of Night to End of Day. The Medieval Costums of Cluny (ed. Susan Boynton & Isabelle Cochelin), Turnhout 2005, s. 191-220.
Kulturhistorisk Leksikon for nordisk middelalder, København 1956-78.
Lexicon für Theologie und Kirche, Freiburg 1957-68.
Lucidarius (udg. Johannes Knudsen), København 1909.
Luther, Martin: Sermon an Sanct Stephans Tag, D. Martin Luthers Werke. Kritische Gesammtausgabe bd. 12, genoptrykt 2003, s. 692-698.
Løffler, J. B.: Rybjerg Kirke, Aarbøger for Nordisk Oldkyndighed og Historie 1873, s. 277-284.
Mackeprang, M.: Vore Landsbykirker, 2. udg., København 1944.
Mackeprang, M.: Jydske Granitportaler, København 1948.
Mansfield, Mary: The Humiliation of Sinners: Public Penance in Thirteenth Century France, Ithaca/New York 1995.
The Manual From Notmark (udg. Knud Ottosen), København 1970.
Martène, Edmond: De antiquis ecclesiæ ritibus 1-4, 1736-38.
Migne, P.-L.: Patrologia latina 1-221, Paris 1844-55.
More, Thomas: Utopia (oversat af Ernst Christiansen), København 1944.
Nyborg, Ebbe: Mikaels-altre, hikuin 3 1977, s. 157-182.
Paxton, Frederick S.: Death by Customary at Eleventh-Century Cluny, From Dead of Night to End of Day. The Medieval Costums of Cluny (ed. Susan Boynton & Isabelle Cochelin), Turnhout 2005, s. 297-318.
Palladius, Peder: En Traktat om de stykker hvormed Guds ord skal holdes ved magt, Peder Palladius’ Danske Skrifter (udg. Lis Jacobsen) bd. 2, København 1914-15, s. 309-322.
Raguin, Virginia Chieffo & Sarah Stanbury (ed.): Women’s Space. Patronage, Place, and Gender in the Medieval Church, New York 2005.
Riou, Yves-Jean: Notre-Damel-La-Grande: Poitiers, Itineraires du Patrimoine 85, Paris 1995.
Rørdam, Holger Fr.: Danske Kirkelove 1-3, København 1883-89.
Sauer, Joseph: Symbolik des Kirchengebäudes und seiner Ausstattung in der Auffassung des Mittelalters, Freiburg im Breisgau 1924.
Schaefer, Herwin: The Origin of the Two-Tower Facade in Romanesque Architecture, The Art Bulletin vol. 27 nr. 2 1945, s. 85-108.
Selhorst, Heinrich: Die Platzordnung im Gläubigenraum der altchristlichen Kirche. Inargural-Dissertation, Münster 1931.
Sheils, W. J. & Diana Wood (ed.): Women in the Church, Oxford 1990.
Storck, H.: Jydske Granitkirker, København 1903.
Tentler, Thomas N.: Sin and Confession on the Eve of the Reformation, New Jersey 1977.
Troels-Lund, Troels Frederik: Dagligt Liv i Norden i det sekstende Aarhundrede. Illustreret Udgave, bd. 6, København 1908-9.
Usener, Hermann: Götternamen. Versuch einer Lehre von der religiösen Begriffsbildung, 2. Aufl., Bonn 1929.
Wienberg, Jes: Den gotiske labyrint, Lund 1993.
Williams, George H.: The Radical Reformation, Philadelphia 1962.
Wilson, Christopher: The Gothic Cathedral. Architecture of the Great Church 1130-1530, re-printed ed., London 2002.
Wilson, David M. & Stephen Moorhouse: Medieval Britain in 1970, Medieval Archaeology vol. 15 1971, s. 124-179.
Downloads
Publiceret
Citation/Eksport
Nummer
Sektion
Licens
Forfatter og Forlag.