Den engelske opstand 1381 FORTOLKNING OG DOKUMENTATION

Forfattere

  • Knud J. V. Jespersen

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.7146/ht.v14i0.52660

Resumé

In the introductory survey of previous research on the Revolt of 1381 it is particularly noted that the event has been used to buttress highly divergent conceptions of history, ranging in the course of time from liberalist to doctrinaire Marxist. There is a two-fold explanation for this: 1) Almost all historians of the revolt have used a compilatory method, thus obviating a systematic critique of the sources; 2) Practically without exception the basis of their knowledge has been the highly problematic narrative source material, which is not only very tendentious, but also complicated by mutual dependence. The latter trait has been almost wholly overlooked by historians of the revolt, who have thus allowed mutually dependent sources to confirm each other.

This underlines the need for a critical and systematic examination of the relationships between the narrative sources for the purpose of eliminating the useless secondary elements. Working on the basis of Harriet Merete Hansen's pioneering studies two crucial characteristics of the narrative material are detected. Firstly, the relationships between the narrative accounts are even closer than one would ever be able to expect beforehand; and Froissart's as well as Anonimalle's accounts are part of that pattern of dependency. Secondly, Anonimalle is not at all the authentic eyewitness account it has always been taken to be, but a late, tendentious (pro-royal) and in most respects secondary narrative. By all indications it was composed by an unusually skillful historian, whose purpose was not a dispassionate account of the course of events, but a vigorous accentuation of Richard ll's role in putting down the revolt.

Combined with a demonstration of Anonimalle as directly polemizing against the pro-aristocratic Froissart account, this leads to the supposition that Anonimalle - traditionally the principal historical source on the revolt - was written during Richard ll's »Second Tyranny« (1396-99) as a piece of royal propaganda purveying a version of events suited to the purposes of the royal power.

Cognizance of this trait as well as the detection of numerous secondary elements in the narrative material opens up new perspectives for research on the 1381 Revolt. Not only has a more reliable basis for further interpretations been secured, but the new and expurgated source basis, consisting principally of official or quasi-official London material, will, perhaps, lend to the interpretations a far greater emphasis on London's internal quarrels than has been the case up to now. Renewed study on the basis of this source revision might well reveal what Ruth Bird and Bertie Wilkinson could only suspect, namely, that the socalled Peasants' Revolt of 1381 was first and foremost a clash between contending political factions in London, in which the peasants were more or less unwitting pawns.

Forfatterbiografi

Knud J. V. Jespersen

N/A

Downloads

Publiceret

1984-01-01

Citation/Eksport

J. V. Jespersen, K. (1984). Den engelske opstand 1381 FORTOLKNING OG DOKUMENTATION . Historisk Tidsskrift, 14, 177–197. https://doi.org/10.7146/ht.v14i0.52660