Mitigating measures in wildlife management: testing lethal and non-lethal scaring on crop-foraging geese

Main Article Content

Ingunn M. Tombre
Gørli Elida Bruun Andersen
Bård-Jørgen Bårdsen

Abstract

Managing geese (Anser and Branta spp.) is challenging but mitigation measures are available that can reduce adverse impacts, such as crop loss from grazing geese. Both non-lethal and lethal scaring offer mechanisms to reduce such impacts, although the latter is often criticised on animal welfare grounds. Conversely, an argument used for shooting some geese is that it acts as a deterrent to others in the flock, so potentially is more effective than non-lethal scaring for moving birds from particular fields. This study therefore compares the effects of lethal scaring (by a person shooting with a shotgun) and non-lethal scaring (someone approaching the geese on foot), as two treatments in an experiment conducted from mid-May to mid-June 2016 in Tønsberg municipality, Norway, an area significantly affected by geese foraging on cultivated fields throughout the growing season. Experimental scaring was conducted at one large property, imposing alternate lethal and non-lethal scaring in nine treatment blocks. Total numbers of geese on the fields, distances between different goose flocks and the scaring field, and flock sizes did not differ significantly between the two treatments in days after scaring. Following application of both scaring methods, geese returned to the scaring field the same day; hence, both methods appeared equally ineffective at reducing the number of geese and their potential to cause crop damage. It should, however, be noted that this study was conducted at just one site in a single season, and more extensive studies are required on this sensitive issue. Meanwhile, lethal scaring implemented in accordance with applicable rules and regulations (e.g. with evidence of economic loss) may have a conflict-mitigating effect, although conflict resolution should not in itself be used to justify lethal scaring.

Article Details

How to Cite
Tombre, I. M., Andersen, G. E. B., & Bårdsen, B.-J. (2026). Mitigating measures in wildlife management: testing lethal and non-lethal scaring on crop-foraging geese. Wildfowl, 76, 35–52. https://doi.org/10.7146/wf.76.173332
Section
Standard Papers

References

Aarseth, J.J. 2023. Complete seasonal surveillance of Greylag Goose (Anser anser) foraging behaviour on dairy grassland and the effect of limited lethal scaring. European Journal of Wildlife Research 69: 53.

Andersen, G.E.B. & Tombre, I.M. 2018. Gjess i Vestfold; en Oversikt over Utbredelse, Antall og Preferanser i Sentrale Områder. NINA Report No. 1402. Norwegian Institute for Nature Research, Norway. Available at https://nva.sikt.no/registration/0198cc681d0e-dbf93ae5-ead0-4a98-b95f-e749b22cece9 (last accessed 12 June 2026). [In Norwegian with English summary.]

Anderson, D.R. 2008. Model Based Inference in the Life Sciences: a Primer on Evidence. Springer Science, New York, USA.

Baxter, A.T. & Allan, J.R. 2008. Use of lethal control to reduce habituation to blank rounds by scavenging birds. Journal of Wildlife Management 72: 1653–1657.

Blackwell, B.F., Bernhardt, G.E. & Dolbeer, R.A. 2002. Lasers as nonlethal avian repellents. Journal of Wildlife Management 66: 250–258.

Burnham, K.P. & Anderson, D.R. 2002. Model Selection and Multimodel Inference: A Practical Information-theoretic Approach. Second Edition. Springer, Inc., New York, USA.

Clausen, K.K., Marcussen, L.K., Knudsen, N., Balsby, T.J.S. & Madsen, J. 2019. Effectiveness of lasers to reduce goose grazing on agricultural grassland. Wildlife Biology 2019: 1–8.

Conover, M.R. 2002. Resolving Human-Wildlife Conflicts. The Science of Wildlife Damage Management. Lewis Publishers/CRC Press, Boca Raton, USA.

Dooley, J.L., Sanders, T.A. & Doherty, P.F. 2010. Mallard response to experimental walkin and shooting disturbance. Journal of Wildlife Management 74: 1815–1824.

Elbers, A.R.W. & Gonzales, J.L. 2021. Efficacy of an automated laser for reducing wild bird visits to the free range area of a poultry farm. Scientific Reports 11: 12779.

Eriksson, L., Johansson, M., Månsson, J., Redpath, S., Sandström, C. & Elmberg, J. 2020. The public and geese: a conflict on the rise? Human Dimensions of Wildlife 25: 421–437.

Eriksson, L., Johansson, M., Månsson, J., Sandström, C. & Elmberg, J. 2024. Adaptive capacity in the multi-level management system of migratory waterbirds: a case study of participatory goose management in Sweden. Journal of Environmental Planning and Management 67: 522–541.

Eythórsson, E., Tombre, I.M. & Madsen, J. 2017. Goose management schemes to resolve conflicts with agriculture: theory, practice and effects. Ambio 46: 231–240.

Fox, A.D. & Abraham, K.F. 2017. Why geese benefit from the transition from natural vegetation to agriculture. Ambio 46: 188–197.

Fox, A.D. & Madsen, J. 2017. Threatened species to super-abundance: the unexpected international implications of successful goose conservation. Ambio 46: 179–187.

Fox, A.D., Elmberg, J., Tombre, I.M. & Hessel, R. 2017. Agriculture and herbivorous waterfowl: a review of the scientific basis for improved management. Biological Reviews 92: 854–877.

Fox, J. 2002. An R and S-PLUS Companion to Applied Regression. Sage Publications, London, UK and Thousand Oak, USA.

Hadidian, J. 2002. Resolving conflicts between people and Canada Geese: the need for comprehensive management approaches. In R.M. Timm & R.H. Schmidt (eds.), Proceedings of the Vertebrate Pest Conference 20: 175–179.

Heldbjerg, H., Nyegaard, T., Clausen, P., Nielsen, R.D. & Fox, A.D. 2025. Citizen science data confirm that expanding non-breeding distributions of goose and swan species correlate with their increasing abundance. Ibis 167: 88–96.

Heldbjerg, H., Clausen, K.K., Balsby, T.J.S., Clausen, P., Nielsen, R.D., Skov, F., Nyegaard, T. & Madsen, J. 2022. Barnacle goose Branta leucopsis derogation shooting effort in relation to abundance and vulnerable crops. Agriculture Ecosystems and Environment 325: 107746.

Holevinski, R.A., Curtis, P.D. & Malecki, R.A. 2007. Hazing of Canada geese is unlikely to reduce nuisance populations in urban and suburban communities. Human Wildlife Conflicts 1: 257–264.

Jensen, G.H., Madsen, J. & Tombre, I. 2016. Hunting migratory geese: Is there an optimal practice? Wildlife Biology 22: 194–203.

Jensen, G.H., Madsen, J., Nagy, S. & Lewis, M. (comps.). 2018. AEWA International Single Species Management Plan for the Barnacle Goose (Branta leucopsis) – Russia/Germany and Netherlands population, East Greenland/Scotland and Ireland population, Svalbard/South-west Scotland population. AEWA Technical Series No. 70, Bonn, Germany. Available at https://www. unep-aewa.org/en/publication/international-single-species-management-plan-barnacle-goose-russiagermany-netherlands (last accessed 12 June 2026).

Klug, P.E., Bukoski, W.P., Shiels, A.B., Kluever, B.M. & Siers, S. 2019. Critical Review of Potential Tools for Reducing Damage by Invasive Rose-ringed Parakeet (Psittacula krameri) on the Hawaiian Islands. Unpublished Final Report QA-2836. USDA APHIS Wildlife Services National Wildlife Research Center, Fort Collins, USA. Available at https://www.kauaiisc.org/wp-content/uploads/QA-2836_RRPA_Control_Tools-FINAL-20190620.pdf (last accessed 12 June 2026).

Koffijberg, K., Schekkerman, H., van der Jeugd, H., Hornman, M. & van Winden, E. 2017. Responses of wintering geese to the designation of goose foraging areas in the Netherlands. Ambio 46: 241–250.

Lazarus, J. 1978. Vigilance, Flock size and domain of danger size in the White-fronted Goose. Wildfowl 29: 135–145.

Lovdata Foundation 2020. Regulations of the Culling of Animals Causing Damage, Dead Game, and the Use of Game in Farming, Research and Zoos; The Game Regulations. The Lovdata Foundation, Oslo, Norway. Available at https://lovdata.no/dokument/SF/forskrift/2020-04-01-565 (last accessed 12 June 2026). [In Norwegian.]

Madsen, J. & Williams, J.H. (comps.). 2012. International Species Management Plan for the Svalbard Population of the Pink-footed Geese Anser brachyrhynchus. AEWA Technical Series No. 48. African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbird Agreement, Bonn, Germany. https://www.unep-aewa.org/en/publication/international-species-management-plan-svalbard-population-pink-footed-goose-ts-no-48 (last accessed 12 June 2026).

Madsen, J., Williams, J.H., Johnson, F.A., Tombre, I.M., Dereliev, S. & Kuijken, E. 2017. Implementation of the first adaptive management plan for a European migratory waterbird population: the case of the Svalbard pink-footed goose Anser brachyrhynchus. Ambio 46: 275–289.

Månsson, J. 2017. Lethal scaring – behavioural and short-term numerical response of greylag goose Anser anser. Crop Protection 96: 258–264.

Månsson, J., Teräväinen, M., Andrén, H., Million, W. & Elmberg, J. 2024. Individual responses of GPS-tagged geese scared off crops by drones or walking humans. Ecological Solutions and Evidence 5: e12386.

Mazerolle, L., Eggins, E., Hine, L. & Higginson, A. 2023. The role of randomized experiments in developing the evidence for evidence-based policing. In D. Weisburd, T. Jonathan-Zamir, G. Perri & B. Hasisi (eds.), The Future of Evidence-based Policing, pp. 147–169. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, UK.

Næss, M.W. 2017. Reindeer herding in a changing world – a comparative analysis. In I. Kelman (ed.), Arcticness: Power and Voices from the North, pp. 59–75. University College London, London, UK. Available at https://muse.jhu.edu/pub/354/oa_edited_volume/chapter/2779871 (last accessed 12 June 2026).

Nilsson, L., Månsson, J., Elmberg, J., Liljebäck, N. & Tombre, I. 2024. Selection of a diversionary field and other habitats by large grazing birds in a landscape managed for agriculture and wetland biodiversity. Ecological Solutions and Evidence 5: e12302.

Nolet, B.A., Kölzsch, A., Elderenbosch, M. & van Noordwijk, A.J. 2016. Scaring waterfowl as a management tool: how much more do geese forage after disturbance? Journal of Applied Ecology 53: 1413–1421.

Pinheiro, J.C & Bates, D.M. 2000. Mixed Effect Models in S and S-PLUS. Springer, New York, USA.

Powolny, T., Jensen, G.H., Nagy, S., Czajkowski, A., Fox, A.D., Lewis, M. & Madsen, J. 2018. (comps.). AEWA International Single Species Management Plan for Greylag Goose (Anser anser) – Northwest/Southwest European Population. AEWA Technical Series No. 71. African-Eurasian Migratory Waterbird Agreement, Bonn, Germany. Available at https://egmp.aewa.info/sites/default/files/download/population_status_reports/AEWA%20International%20Single%20Species%20Management%20Plan%20for%20the%20Greylag%20Goose_NW_SW%20European%20Population.pdf (last accessed 12 June 2026).

R Core Team 2024. R: a Language and Environment for Statistical Computing. R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria. https://www.R-project.org.

Rist, L., Campbell, B.M. & Frost, P. 2012. Adaptive management: where are we now? Environmental Conservation 40: 5–18.

Robai, C.I., Nyaga, J.M., Karuri, H., Elmberg, J. & Månsson, J. 2024. Reducing the number of grazing geese on agricultural fields – effectiveness of different scaring techniques. Crop Protection 177: 106552.

Seltmann, M.W., Ylitalo, A.-K., Piironen, A., Store, E., Heikkinen, J., Heim, W., Piha, M., Seimola, T., Laaksonen, T. & Forsman, J.T. 2025. Arctic migrating barnacle geese utilize accommodation fields in a new agricultural staging area. Journal of Applied Ecology 62: 317–328.

Simonsen, C.E., Madsen, J., Tombre, I.M. & Nabe-Nielsen, J. 2016. Is it worthwhile scaring geese to alleviate damage to crops? – An experimental study. Journal of Applied Ecology 53: 916–924.

Sørensen, S.L., Madsen, J. & Balsby, T.J.S. 2026. An analysis of farmers’ experiences with deterrence methods and investment in mitigation of agricultural crop damage caused by geese. PLoS One 21(2): e0341807.

Statistics Norway 2026. Felled Small Game, by Region, Small Game and Interval. Statistics Norway, Oslo, Norway. Available at https://www.ssb.no/en/statbank/table/14380 (last accessed 12 June 2026).

Tombre, I.M., Brunner, A., D’Hondt, B., Düttmann, H., Enzerink, R., Fox, A., Feige, N., Heldbjerg, H., Herraro, B., Huysentruyt, F., Kostiushyn, V., Månsson, J., McKenzie, R., Mensink, G., Meyers, E., Midtgaard, L., Nilsson, L., Nolet, B., Petrovych, O., Post, K., Scallan, D., Teräväinen, M., Uldal, C., Westebring, M. & Jensen, G.H. 2019. An overview of the management measures for geese in range states of the European Goose Management Platform. AEWA EGMP Publication No. 10. African Eurasian Migratory Waterbird Agreement, Bonn, Germany.

Vickery, J.A. & Summers, R.W. 1992. Cost-effectiveness of scaring brent geese Branta b. bernicla from fields of arable crops by a human bird scarer. Crop Protection 11: 480–484.

Visitor Centre Wetland Ilene 2026. https://www.ilene.no/en/ (last accessed 12 June 2026).

Werner, S.J. & Clark, L. 2006. Effectiveness of a motion-activated laser hazing system for repelling captive Canada Geese. Wildlife Society Bulletin 34: 2–7.

Zuur, A.F., Ieno, E.N. & Elphick, C.S. 2010. A protocol for data exploration to avoid common statistical problems. Methods in Ecology and Evoltuion 1: 3–14.

Zuur, A.F., Ieno, E.N., Walker, N.J., Saveliev, A. & Smith, G.M. 2009. Mixed Effects Models and Extensions in Ecology with R. Springer, New York, USA.