Ledelse og Erhvervsøkonomi/Handelsvidenskabeligt Tidsskrift/Erhvervsøkonomisk Tidsskrift, Bind 23 (1959)

The Use of Management Reports in the Insurance Business (in the United States1).

G. Graversen 2)

Insurance theory, principles and practice seem to be thoroughly covered in a large number of U. S. textbooks, and these are also subjects for study in U. S. universities. In the rapidly growing insurance companies there is also wide education and training in the same subjects.

Organization and management in the insurance business seem, on the other hand, not
to have been subjects for research or education, but organization and management are
discussed in internal seminars for office people.

A description of the use of management reports in the insurance business will therefore not cover general practice or all reports in the management fields. As management and management reports have to be observed in the light of the education and training of insurance personnel, because some reports are combined with training programs, at the end of this article a description will be given of education and training in a university and in an insurance company.

Management and Management Report.

As in other fields, it is very difficult to define the word "Manager". I have discussed the definition used in the insurance business with many executives and professors, but it is not possible to come to an exact definition of "Manager". The title "Manager" implies a decision-making person, but it seems that this title is also used in other cases, e. g. about leaders of insurance agencies, who have no decisions to make. Therefore, in this article the words management and manager will be used in a broad sense, whether it is in connection with management reports or not.

The words "Management Report" can also be discussed, because Management Reports can cover both reports to higher management and to lower management, but also in this case, the description will follow the interest in the reports rather than formal procedure.

The organizationplan in the insurance business differs from one company to another,
but it seems that the following outline gives a relatively general outlook of the upper
level of an insurance company:

1) Artiklen omfatter et uddrag af en rapport til E. P. A. fra en studierejse til U. S. A. - januar/marts 1959

2) Lektor, statsaut. revisor.

Side 190

DIVL3573

Organizational Chart

The U. S. insurance companies visited were of a very large size, but it seems that the number of vice presidents is large, although titles sometimes seem to be part of public relations work. In some companies there is an Executive Committee meeting on call, consisting of president, some vice presidents, and directors.

Use of Management Reports.

I. Annual Reports.

A. The Insurance Co. — Public Annual Report.


DIVL3597

The Annual Report will be made out in a good-looking financial report form and in
a handy size. The cover page gives the name of the Company and the year covered
in the report.

Inside will often be found names and pictures of members of the Board of Directors.
These people represent "the upper ten" - normally 9 to 24 members from the area in

Side 191

which the company operates. The members get no fixed salary, but an amount per
meeting, at which it is so often necessary to make special decisions, e. g. approval of
the president's Annual Report. Meetings seem to be held mostly three times a year.

After presentation of the Board of Directors in the report follows a message from
the president, reporting on the last business year and possibly commenting on plans
for the future.

The following pages show statements for both the last and the foregoing year, indicating
changes in Assets, Liabilities, and Surplus Funds plus per-centages for easier
reading of the statement.

The additional pages give more detailed descriptions and statistical figures showing the increase or decrease in the Company's economic and working operation, figures for owned bonds, stocks, etc., and final pages list names and pictures of executive offices and addresses of agency offices.

a. 'Textexample of a Published Statement.


DIVL3603
Side 192

b. Example of Long-range trend From a Published Annual Report.

The example, from an Annual Report, gives a good picture of the increase in the life
insurance business in the U. S.


DIVL3617

NEW LIFE INSURANCE ISSUED (Annual Totals by Years) *) Does not include group insurance issued on U. S. Government employees.


DIVL3620

INSURANCE IN FORCE (Cumulative Totals by Years)

Side 193

DIVL3614

GROWTH OF ASSETS (Cumulative Totals by Years)

After the Board of Directors' approval the President's Annual Report will be presented for approval to the stockholders in an annual meeting. The annual meeting of all companies chartered by the same state will always be held on the same date. Stockholders, therefore, are able to participate in only one company meeting in the same state.

B. Annual Report to State Insurance Departments.


DIVL3640

Each of the 49 States in the U. S. has a State Insurance Department with a Commissioner (political appointment) as a head and a large inspection staff. The annual report to the Commissioner is in a very detailed and statistical form, as it will be inspected by the Insurance Department.

There are special laws and Insurance Department regulations in the several states, but all commissioners meet once or twice a year in a meeting of the National Association of Insurance Commissioners, and try to come to an agreement in case of new problems. The individual commissioner is quite free to express his opinions as the representative of the insurance industry in his state.

Side 194

Each insurance company will be inspected simultaneously every third year by inspectors from all the State Insurance Departments concerned, but for this purpose the areas of representation (of the up to 49 U. S. State Insurance Departments) are divided into 6 zones. If the Company operates in 3 zones only e. g., the Company will be visited by only three inspectors, who have to review the figures in the Annual Reports.

The Commissioner in each state will publish an Annual Report with statistical information
on the insurance companies' operations in the state.

Example of Heading of pages in the Commissioner's Annual Report (Michigan):


DIVL3642

Larger insurance companies are registered in the State Departments and send
examples of all insurance records to the State Insurance Department. Smaller insurance
companies must be inspected more carefully and more often than every three years.

C. Annual Reports to Policyowners.

In public relations work it seems that most insurance companies send a short Annual
Report to all policyowners.

This statement includes figures indicating the growth of the insurance company and
public relations comments.

II. Monthly Report to Top Executives.

The basis of the Insurance Company's economic and working operations is the annual
budget, which is divided into individual accounts in the total budget as well as into
yearly and monthly figures.

The actual figures will be compiled in different departments and the summary figures
worked out on tabulating machines and reported to the top executives shortly after the
beginning of a new month.

Side 195

III. The "Build-Up" of the Budget and Budget Reports.


DIVL3666

The different Detail Reports have the same "Head" as the Recapitulation Report.

Side 196

V. The Use of Production Reports.


DIVL3673
Side 197

VI. Education and Training Programs.

A. University Program (Example) (Texas Christian University)

PROGRAM FOR PEOPLE IN THE INSURANCE BUSINESS

Extensive course offerings in insurance are available through the Texas Christian University Evening College. These Courses are designed primarily for persons actively engaged in the insurance industry who wish to increase their knowledge of this dynamic subject by a study of principles and practices.

Professional Designations.

Texas Christian University is one of the cooperating institutions designated by the American Institute for Property and Liability Underwriters, Incorporated, and the American College of Life Underwriters to prepare students to sit for the Chartered Property and Casualty Underwriter (C. P. C. U.) and the Chartered Life Underwriter (C. L. U.) examinations. The C. P. C. U. and C. L. U. designations are recognized as signifying attainment of the highest professional competence in the property-casualty and life insurance industries. Texas Christian University offers courses to specifically prepare students for all C. P. C. U. and C. L. U. examinations.

A complete program of basic courses in property insurance is also available. These courses have as their objectives 1) enabling students to gain a general understanding and appreciation of the principles and practices of insurance, and 2) providing students with a solid basis of insurance knowledge upon which they can build by then continuing with the more advanced C. P. C. U. curricula. Moreover, the University makes its facilities available for classes fostered by thy Life Underwriter Training Council (L.U.T. C).

Degree and Certificate Programs.

A Bachelor of Science in Commerce degree with a major in insurance can be obtained through the T.C.U. Evening College. Programs that culminate in the awarding of a certificate in either life or property-casualty insurance are available for students not wishing to spend the time required to earn the Bachelor of Science in Commerce degree. The certificate programs involve successful completion of two years of college work (approximately 60 semester hours). All courses necessary to prepare students for either the C.L.U. or the C.P.C.U. examinations are included in the certificate programs.

Institutes and Seminars

The insurance department welcomes the opportunity to cooperate with insurance organizations in arranging institutes and seminars. Meetings of this nature serve a vital continuing education function by stimulating a cross fertilization of ideas under the optimum learning conditions provided by a studious atmosphere. Several successful meetings have been held on our campus.

Side 198

B. Training in an Insurance Company

(Example I)


DIVL3734

THE TRAVELERS SALES MANAGEMENT TRAINING PROGRAM

Side 199

DIVL3734

THE TRAVELERS SALES MANAGEMENT TRAINING PROGRAM

(Example II)

Southwestern Life Insurance Company

Sales Training Program (3 years)

1. Basic Course
I Introduction to Life Underwriting
II Life Insurance Salesmanship

2. Intermediate Course
Career Course in Life Underwriting

3. Advanced Course
I Business Insurance Course
II Tax Insurance Course

L. U. T. C. (Life Underwriter Training Council) (2 years)
- Institutional -

C. L. U. (Chartered Life Underwriter) (4 years)
- Academic -