Geografisk Tidsskrift, Bind 80 (1980)SEDIMENTS AND DYNAMICS IN THE VARDE Å ESTUARYJESPER BARTHOLDY Side 64
Bartholdy,
Jesper: Sediments and Dynamics in the Varde Å Estuary.
The Varde Å estuary is supplied with material from two sources: the drainage area and the turbidity maximum in the N-part of Ho Bugt. The first supplies bed load and suspended material, whereas the latter supplies fine-grained, flocculated material only. The sediments
and the dynamics related to sediment transport in
Jesper Bartholdy,
M.Sc., research scholarship, Geographical Institute,
1. MATERIAL SUPPLIED FROM THE DRAINAGE AREAFig. 1 shows a typical grain size distribution of bed load material supplied to the estuary from the drainage area. Using the Folk and Ward (1957) parameters, the material can be generally characterized as follows: The log-probability distribution shows two distinct inflection points, one near 0.75 $ (0.59 mm) and another near 2.4 3> (0.19 mm). This is in agreement with the distributions found by Visher (1969) and by Sagoe & Visher (1977) who interpret these two inflection points as separating traction- saltation and suspension populations. Midleton (1976) argued that the »fine« inflection point depends on the wash load content and, consequently, cannot be dependent on the hydraulics, but on the supply of fine-grained material only. He also advocates that the »coarse« inflection point should be interpreted as separating material moving almost exclusively as bed load, and material moving in suspension from time to time when the river reaches the »dominant« discharge. The sample shown in fig. 1 was collected in the middle of a straight river course 12 km upstream from the mouth of Varde Å by means of a box sampler which traps the movable bed load material. After sieving, the different subsamples were analysed in a settling tube where the settling velocities in pure water at 20°C were determined. Table 1 shows the relation between sieving diameter and settling velocity. Simultaneously
with collecting the bed load sample, the Depth D = 1.29 m,
mean velocity over depth V = 0,565 Equation (1) was
constructed using the data presented in The equation predicts the fall velocity Wj at a given temperature T (10°<T<20°C), from the fall velocity at 20°C, W2O (2-10'3< W2O <2.5 -10'1 m/s). The last column in table 1 shows the fall velocity at 14°C fitting the actual, measured water temperature. These values were calculated using equation (1) and the measured fall velocities at 20°C. According to
Engelund and Hansen (1972) the effective Where d denotes the mean fall diameter. This was in the actual case determined to 0.556 mm by means of the sieveing analysis, table 1, and the Subcommittee data on fall velocity of spheres. Side 65
When solving
equation 2 and 3 by iteration, Uf" was found On the basis of data from Guy et al. (1966), Engelund (1973) found that grains with smaller fall velocity than Wc = 0.8 • U'r- are transported in suspension. In the actual case this gave a critical fall velocity of 0.22 m/s, which by means of table 1 can be transformed to a critical sieve diameter of 2.5 $ (0.18 mm), very close the »fine« inflection point in fig. 1. The results described here therefore suggest that the interpretation of the »fine« inflection point, in accordance with Visher's analysis, should be the separation of bed load- and suspended load. The problem with different wash load supplies, such as mentioned by Midleton (1976), could probably affect the amount of fine-grained material present in the bed load, and therefore move the »fine« inflection point up and down in the log/probability diagram; the grain size at which the inflection point appears, however, is not likely to reflect this supply. 1.2 Wash load versus suspended bed load material The suspended materal is divided into two parts, suspended bed load and wash load material. In order to investigate the share of each type, there were, simultaneously with the earlier mentioned measurements, collected two water samples, one Cs from 0.10 m below the water surface and one Cfo from 0.10 m above the river bed. Cs contained 16.2 mg/1 and Cb 18.5 mg/1 (filtered through Watman GFF filters). As wash load per
definition is independent of the immediate According to
Einstein (1950) the suspended bed load material In the actual case, Cy is measured as a summation of both suspended bed load and wash load material. Therefore, (4) should be rewritten as (5) by means of the approximation that Z can be calculated by substituting W with the mean fall velocity of the suspended bed load material: (5): Cy, Ca denote the
total concentration of suspended material The mean fall velocity of the suspended bed load material was calculated to 0.006 m/s by truncation of the grain size distribution, at the critical grain size, according to the earlier mentioned suspension criterion. The solution of equation (5) gave a wash load content as high as 16.0 mg/1, which means that 0.1 m above the river bed only (18.5 - 16.0) 2.5 mg/1 was suspended bed load material. The transport
rate of this material was found using (6): where \\ and \2
were determined to 0.8 and -1.0 respectively (7): These
calculations gave qs = 0,6 -10"^ kg/s m2m2 and qwa =
The measurements
described here were carried out in a Side 66
Therefore much coarser material is likely to be brought into suspension in flom situations. According to Midleton (1976) the »coarse« inflection point (in this case at 0.75 $ (0.59 mm)) is inherited from these situations. The present results show, however, that in normal situations most of the suspended material supplied to the estuary from the drainage area, is wash load and only a small proportion is suspended bed load material. 2. BED LOAD TRANSPORT IN THE ESTUARYThe bed load
material supplied to the estuary from the In the channel reach between 4-7 km upstream from the mouth, the bed load material builds up channel bars, giving the estuary cross profile an irregular appearance. The transformation from alluvial to non-alluvial conditions is illustrated in table 2 showing the change in the Manning number M down the estuary. The values in table 3 represent I0 and Dmax in four cross sections of the estuary during a spring-tide situation at maximum bed shear stress. For all four cross sections this maximum occurred during the ebb period. These values give rise to a calculation of the variations in competence in the estuary, based on an iterative reading of Shield's curve (guess diameter, calculate Reynold's number, read 6c, calculate from this the new diameter etc). The results are shown in table 4. The calculations imply that the whole friction velocity is at disposal for sediment transport, which - in contrast to capacity calculations - is a reasonable implication here. The results demonstrate that there is a drastic decrease in competence in the channel reach from 7.5-3.0 km upstream from the estuary mouth; and that this decrease in a normal spring-tide situation affects particle sizes which are present in the bed load supply from the drainage area. Fig. 2 shows how mean grain size (mz), standard deviation (a) and skewness (sk) vary in the estuary. It is here illustrated how the mean grain size rises from the 0.5 mm valid for bed load supplied from the drainage area to 0.7 mm near the island 4.3 km upstream from the mouth see fig. 3. From here the mean grain size decreases to approx. 0.2 mm at the submerged bar outside the estuary. This variation
reflects the above-mentioned decrease in Side 67
further
emphasizes this interpretation, with a minimum The rapid
increase in values of skewness up to + 0.5 mm This is primarily a result of mixing with fine-grained, flocculated material from the turbidity maximum which in this region increases its influence in the downstream direction. That it is mixing and not sorting which causes this overall change in character of sediments downstream of the island is illustrated in the values of standard deviation. This changes from 0.8-0.7 $ (moderately sorted) to 2.4 <i> (very poorly sorted) over the same reach. According to the results described here, the bed load transport through the estuary is affected by decreasing competence; which results in a mean grain size maximum about 4 km upstream from the estuary mouth, and the development of channel bars tending to narrow the cross section of the estuary. The bed load material which escapes this region is mingled with fine-grained, flocculated material and transported downstream to settle at a submerged bar just outside the estuary mouth. 3. MATERIAL SUPPLIED FROM THE TURBIDITY MAXIMUMIn his paper, Pejrup (1980), discusses the existence of a turbidity maximum in the northern part of Ho Bugt. The material-rich water from here is carried up the estuary with the flood current where the major part of the suspended material deposits at high-tide slack water. In the following ebb current, this material is subjected to resuspension and brought back to Ho Bugt. This resuspension goes on during Side 68
the first part
of the ebb period; at late ebb, the estuary is
Outside the estuary mouth, the tide is clockwise rotating and thus forces the freshwater to leave the mouth area in a more southern direction than from where the estuary is filled during flood tide. This means that the salt water appears very quickly in the estuary after low-tide slack water. The dynamic conditions just inside the mouth during two tidal cycles are shown in fig. 4. It is here clearly demonstrated how sensitive the concentration of suspended material is, to weather conditions. The first tidal period was characterized by calm weather, and the second by a gale from the SW. During the latter cycle the concentrations of suspended material increased by a factor three, whereas the pattern of variation remained unchanged. Roughly this pattern can be described by dividing the variations into the following 4 phases: Phase 1: first half of the flood period when the material-rich water from the turbidity maximum in the bay flows into the estuary making a peak on the concentration curve at maximum flood current velocity. Phase 2:
second half of the flood period when the material
Phase 3:
beginning of the ebb-period when the resuspension Phase 4: the rest of the ebb period when the concentration decreases to the lowest values of the whole tidal period due to the supplies of relatively pure water from the drainage area. The concentrations of suspended material were found by filtration of depth-integrated water samples (0.75 1) through Whatmann GFF filters, as prescribed in Whatmann's Publication No. 604. The above-mentioned dynamic conditions, with relatively high concentrations of suspended material at high-tide slack water, result in mud-flat deposits along the estuarine banks, consisting of fine-grained, flocculated material from the turbidity maximum in Ho Bugt. As stated by Pejrup (1980), this material is of both marine and of fluvial origin. The latter has an organic content of 30-50% (combusted at 500°C) against roughly 10% in the material from the turbidity maximum. Biological processes in estuarine waters and in the uppermost sediment layers tend to mobilize organic matter (Biggs 1970) and remove it from estuaries; apart from this, there also exists a sedimentological contribution to the removal of organic matter, such as illustrated by the laboratory experiments presented in fig. 5. The experiments showed that, in salt water, organic matter will react much weaker to flocculation than minerogene matter does; this may lead to a selective sedimentation of minerogene material in estuaries, whereas the organic part easier escapes to the ocean. The experiments also showed that the flocculated freshwater wash load material had almost the same grain size distribution as the flocculated suspended material from the brackisch part of the turbidity maximum. 4. THE DEVELOPMENT SINCE 1804On the map fig. 6 it is shown how new marsh areas have grown up since 1804 in the area W of the bridge across the estuary just inside the mouth. During the same period, the channel reach between 7.5-3 km inside the mouth has narrowed considerably. On the map from 1804 - only a section W of the bridge is shown in fig. 6 - there is no sign of the island about 4 km upstream from the mouth. By 1870, the island was a small, 25 m wide bar, which in the period until 1955 grew to an approximate width of 100 m. It is remarkable that this growth did not cause any erosion in the adjacent banks; rather on the contrary, both up- and downstream from the island center the banks have been moving forward, as in the rest of the inner estuary. In the region upstream of the island the narrowing has typically taken place by deposition of bars (bank-near channel bars or point bars) built up of coarse material, stabilized by vegetation and fine-grained material, and thereafter grown together with the original banks by deposition of mud flats in the shelter between bar and bank. Downstream of the island, the narrowing has taken place as mud flat deposition only. Side 69
Myrick and
Leopold (1963) found that the well-known also is valid in small tidal estuaries. On the basis of theoretical considerations they determined the exponent b to 0.77 and on the basis of measurements in a tidal area to 0.71. This hydraulic geometry is related to a tidal creek which drains no upland. By using Inglis and Aliens (1957) data from the Thames estuary, this exponent can be determined to 0.86, i.e. close to the value found by Myrick and Leopold. By measurements in the Varde Å estuary this exponent was determined to 1.6, a value which reflects the absence of equilibrium with a rapidly narrowing upper estuary. It is believed that the reason is an interaction between the rising sea level and the final stage in the development of the peninsula Skallingen. The rising sea level (approx. 0.1 cm/year) has lowered the maximum water surface gradient in the estuary. During the last 100-200 years this has apparently reached a critical stage where coarse material supplied to the estuary can no longer be carried through it, and consequently is left building up channel bars. During the same period the peninsula Skallingen has reached its present form, offering an effective protection for the Ho Bugt area against the North Sea. Earlier, when Skallingen was no more than a sand bar, there has probably not been sufficient shelter to build up a turbidity maximum with the now found high concentrations in the northern part of Ho Bugt; consequently, the sedimentation of fine-grained material in the estuary at that time has been limited compared to the actual conditions. CONCLUSION1. The
log/probability plot of the bed load material supplied
Side 70
inflection points. One near 0.75 <i> (0.59 mm) and another near 2.4 $ (0.19 mm). Measurements show that the fine inflection point is in agreement with the actual dynamic conditions separating bed load and suspended load. 2. Basedon data
from Report No. 12, Subcommittee on The equation
predicts the fall velocity Wj at a given temperature
3. In »normal« situations, less than 5% of the total, suspended material supplied to Varde Å estuary from the drainage area consists of suspended bed load material, the rest is wash load. 4. In the channel reach from 7.5-3.0 km upstream from the estuary mouth, there is a drastic decrease in competence. In a normal spring-tide situation this decrease is affecting particle sizes present in the bed load supplied from the drainage area. 5. The bed load transport through the estuary is affected by the decreasing competence; resulting in a mean grain size maximum about 4 km upstream from the estuary mouth, and, in the same region, development of channel bars which tend to narrow the cross section of the estuary. The bed load material escaping this region is mingled with fine-grained, flocculated material, and with this transported farther for deposition at a submerged bar just outside the estuary mouth. 6. At flood-tide, the inflowing water is part of a turbidity maximum in the northern part of Ho Bugt. At high-tide slack water, the suspended material deposits inside the estuary. During ebb-tide, it is resuspended and the estuary bottom is »washed clean«. At the end of the ebb period, the estuary is filled with relatively pure fresh water from the drainage area. 7. Organic matter reacts much weaker upon flocculation in salt water than minerogene material does. In estuaries, this difference may lead to selective sedimentation of minerogene material, whereas the organic materialeasier escapes to the ocean. 8. The upper part of the estuary is narrowing very quickly giving it a pronounced funnel shape. The exponent b in the regime formula W= aQ"3 was determined to 1.6, which is high compared with the expected value between 0.7 and 0.9. This non-equilibrium state is believed to be a result of the rising sea level and the relatively new sheltering effect of the peninsula Skallingen. LIST OF SYMBOLSa reference level
above the bottom; empirically determined
b empirically
determined exponent Cy concentration
of suspended material at level y above d mean fall
diameter D depth g accelleration
of gravity I0 water surface
gradient (energy gradient) M Manning number
qs transport
rate of suspended bed load material R(j Reynold's
number for grains with the diameter d T temperature
Ur- friction
velocity left after form drag correction Wc critical fall
velocity before suspension K V. Kårmån's
constant Øc critical
Shield's parameter before transport RESUMEVarde Å's
estuarium tilføres materiale både fra oplandet i form af
Ved målinger 12 km opstrøms for Varde As munding fandtes overensstemmelse mellem suspensionskriteriet Wc = o.B'U'r (Engelund 1973), og det fine knæk på kornstørrelsesfordelingskurven (log/sandsynligheds plot). Endvidere fandtes, at der i en »normal« situation tilføres mindre and 5% af den samlede suspenderede transport i form af egentlig suspenderet bed-load materiale, resten udgøres af wash load. Målinger
foretaget i en springtids-situation viste, at estuariets
Side 71
mundingen, og at dette berører kornstørrelser, der dagligt tilføres estuariet. Competancefaldet bevirker en opkoncentrering af grovkornede partikler og aflejring af channel bars i det nævnte område. Bed-load materialet, der transporteres gennem området, blandes med finkornet materiale fra Ho Bugt og transporteres videre gennem estuariet til aflejring på en barre kystværts for mundingen. I flodperioden tilføres estuariet vand fra et turbiditetsmaksimum, der befinder sig i den nordlige del af Ho Bugt. Ved højvandsstrømstille aflejres det tilførte materiale midlertidigt for, i den efterfølgende ebbeperiode, atter at resuspenderes og føres tilbage til bugten. I slutningen af ebbeperioden fyldes estuariet med relativt rent ferskvand fra oplandsafstrømningen. Ved et laboratorieforsøg med suspensionsmateriale fra estuariet er det vist, at den organiske del reagerer svagere på flokkulering i saltvand end den minerogene del, hvilket kan føre til en selektiv aflejring af minerogent materiale medens organisk materiale lettere undslipper til havet. De indre dele af estuariet har gennem de sidste 200 år gennemgået en drastisk indsnævring, som har bragt estuariet ud af formligevægt. Exponenten bi regimeformlen W = aQ er således blevet bestemt til l .6, hvilket er cirka en faktor 2 større end den forventede værdi på ca. 0.8 (Myrick og Leopold 1963). Denne uligevægt forventes at være betinget af det stigende havspejl (nedsat competance) og den relativt nye beskyttelse af området som følge af Skallingens opvækst og inddigning. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTSThe funds for this investigation were provided by the Danish Ministry of environment. I am pleased to express my gratitude to Senior Lecturer B. Hasholt and M. Pejrup, M.Sc. for helpful criticism and cooperation during the work. Thanks are also due to Engineer K. Pedersen, and to the staff at the Danish Isotope Center. Moreover, I wish to thank Kirsten Winther for improving my English version. REFERENCESBartholdy, J.
(1979): »Sedimenttransport i Varde Å's Estuarium«,
Bartholdy, J.
(1980): »Sediment Transport in the Varde Å Estuary,
Biggs, R. B.
(1970): »Sources and distribution of suspended sediment
Cameron, W.
M. og Pricthard, D. W. (1963): »Estuaries« in »The
Det Danske
Hedeselskabs kulturtekniske afdelings hydrometiske
Dyer, K. R.
(1973): »Estuaries: A Physical Introduction«.
Einstein, H. A. (1950): »The Bed-load function for sediment transportation in open channel flows«, Tech. Bull. No. 1026, Sept. 1950, U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Soil Cons. Service, Washington, D. C. Engelund, F.
A. (1964): »Flow resistance and hydraulic radius«.
Engelund, F.
A. og Hansen, E. (1972): »A Monograph on sediment
Engelund, F.
A. og Christensen, L. (1969): »Lagdelte inhomogene
Engelund, F.
A. (1973): »Steady transport of moderately graded
Engelund, F.
A. og Pedersen, F. B. (1974): »Hydraulik«. Engelund, F.
A. og Fredsøe, J. (1976): »A sediment transport model
Folk, R. L.
og Ward, C. W. (1957): »Brazo River bar: A study in the
Gry, H.
(1942): »Das Wattenmeer bei Skallingen«, Folia
Geographica Guy, H. P.,
Simons, D. B. and Richardson, E. V. (1966): »Summary
Hasholt, B.
(1968): »En undersøgelse af hydrologiske forhold i den
Hasholt, B.
(1972): »Materialevandringen i Karlsgårde Sø og dens
Hasholt, B.
(1976): »Varde Å - Hydrologi og Materialetransport i
Hasholt, B.
(1978): »En undersøgelse af materialeaflejringer og
sedimentationsforhold Hjulstrøm, F.
(1935): »Studies of the morphological activity of rivers
Horrer, P. L.
(1976): »Methods and devices for measuring currents«
Inglis, C. C.
og Allen, F. H. (1957): »The regime of the Thames
Jacobsen, N.
K. (1964): »Træk af Tøndermarskens naturgeografi Jacobsen, N.
K. (1976): »Skallingen - Naturens laboratorium for
Leopold, L.
B. og Maddock, T. (1953): »The hydraulic geometry of
Luneburg, H.,
Schaumann, K. og Wellershaues, S. (1975): »Physiographie
Lyshede, J.
M. (1955): »Hydrologic Studies of Danish Water Courses«.
Myrick, R. M.
og Leopold, L. B. (1963): »Hydraulic Geometry of Middleton, G.
V. (1976): »Hydraulic interpretation of sand size
Pedersen, K.
og Hasholt, B. (1978): »Forekomst og transport af
Pejrup, M.
(1979): »Sedimenttransport og hydrografi i Ho Bugt«,
Pejrup, M.
(1980): »The turbidity maximum in the northern part of
Post må, H.
(1967): »Sediment transport and sedimentation in the
Raudkivi, A.
J. (1976): »Loose Boundary Hudraulics«. 2nd ed.
Report No. 12
(1958): »Some fundamentals of particle size analysis«.
Sagoe, K.-M.
O. and Visher G. S. (1977): »Population breaks in
Visher, G. S.
(1969): »Grain Size distributions and depositional
processes«. Whatman
Publication No. 604. Wood, P. A.
(1977): »Control of variation in suspended sediment
Yalin, M. S.
(1977): »Mechanics of Sediment Transport«. 2nd ed.
|