Geografisk Tidsskrift, Bind 89 (1989)Late-holocene coastal evolution in the Hanstholm-Hjardemaal region, NW Denmark. Morphology, sediments and datingDan Bowman, Christian Christiansen & Mordeckai Magaritz Side 49
Bowman, Dan, Christiansen, Christian & Magaritz, Mordeckai: Late-holocene coastal evolution in the Hanstholm-Hjardemaal region, NW Denmark. Morphology, sediments and dating. Geografisk Tidsskrift 89:49-57. København 1989. Raised
gravelly spits and beach ridges were studied as
components Two gravelly spits up to 8-9 m above the present sea level were dated 4000-4700 YBP by oyster shells, i.e. oj"late Littorina/Tapes subboreal transgression. Dating of organic matter suggested general dune stabilization within the study area from 471 YBP. The data suggest that the study area operated as a semi- enclosed and sheltered embayment. The ridges indicate transgression of sediment masses arrested from the longshore drift, superimposed by moderate eolian accumulation. Keywords: Raised
beaches, transgression, regression, dune building,
Dan Bowman,
Department of Geography, Ben-Gurion University Christian
Christiansen, Institute of Geology, University of
Mordeckai
Magaritz, Department of Isotope Research, Weizmann
The post-glacial uplift of NW Jutland has raised both submarine and coastal sediments which make up raised shorelines in the emerged areas in the form of beach ridges and gravelly spits. Ridge complexes were explained in Australia by Thorn (1983) as swash-aligned, indicating regressive depositional sequences subject to episodic wind erosion. He found ridges to consist of an eolian cap of low- angle cross-bedded strata, a beach face and nearshore sediments. Hine (1979) observed that berm development at the outer end of recurved spits may appear as ridges and swales. Raised gravel spits have not received much attention in the literature compared to raised gravelly beach ridges (Petersen, 1976; Gry, 1979). The aim of this study is to resolve and define the main morpho-sedimentological components in the Hanstholm region, NW Denmark and to date and relate them to the late-holocene coastal evolution. STUDY AREAThe study area covers 49 km2 on the NW coast of Jutland (fig. 1) and is located in a former sound. The low-lying areas express the entrenchment of the Weichsel ice into the Danian rocks, and also reflect the relatively erodible Senonian formations. Hanstholm and Hjardemaal stand out as stacks and indicate an arc of Danian chalk surrounding a Maastrichtian core. Their sharp and steep slopes may suggest marine undermining, or tectonic activity in the Tertiary and Quaternary (Hansen & Håkonsson, 1980). The main sediment drift along the coast bypassed the study area, and proceeded towards the northern tip of Jutland, forming the so-called Skagen formation in the Kattegat (Floden, 1973). The general
southward surface drainage in the study Side 50
effect of the coastal dunes. The latter show a progressive coastward increase in height, indicating an eolian phase nourished by the beach. The beaches show a pronounced retreat averaging 2.5 m/y (Hansen, 1968). A major period of coastal eolian activity in the study area is mentioned from 1550 AD to about 1800 AD (Bruel, 1918; Christiansen & Bowman, 1986). MethodField examination and air photos to a scale of 1:15,000 and 1:21,000 as well as topographic maps to a scale of 1:20,000, 1:50,000 and 1:100,000 were used for morphological analyses. In the field trenches were dug across the ridges down to a depth of 1.8 m. At each pit-exposure the structure, the stratigraphy and the soil profile were documented and the different sand units were sampled. Additional shallow pits and trenches were dug all over the area to ascertain former findings. Organic material, suitable for radiocarbon dating, was retrieved from several pits. Sand size analyses were carried out using the standard sieving method. The log-hyperbolic distribution was fitted to the samples using the method of maximum likelihood (Barndorff-Nielsen, 1977). A computer program for estimating the parameters from the log-hyperbolic distribution (Jensen, 1983) was applied. Fig. 2 shows the graphic interpretation of the parameters, cp and e are the slopes of the two assymptotes to the hyperbola. They are equivalent to the "fine grade" and the "coarse grade" of Bagnold (1941). n is the location of the intersection point of the two assymptotes on the x-axis, and parameter o is a sorting parameter. The skewness and the kurtosis of the hyperbolic distribution are very complicated functions (Barndorff-Nielsen & Blaesild, 1981). Throughout the triangle (fig. 3) X and £ express relatively, in a qualitative sense, the skewness and the kurtosis. Radiocarbon measurements were done at the radiocarbon laboratory of the Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel. Carbonate samples were treated by acid and the organic matter was combusted in dry oxygen stream. The CO2 was purified and converted to ethane. For measurements, proportional gas counting of ethane was performed (Carmi et al., 1971; Carmi, 1978). The half life used was 5568 years. Ridge MorphologyThe spacing and orientation of the multiple ridges in the study area follow a well-organized morphological pattern (figs. 4, 5). The ridges consist of continuous parallel lines of hummocky low relief 2.5-3.5 m high, including deflation saddles a few tens of meters wide. Strips of lowlands separate the ridges which are fully vegetated and stabilized through sand-binding grasses. Their cross section is almost symmetrical, i.e. the typically eolian asymmetry is not observed. The ridges also show no evidence of beach morphology; neither of berms, nor of washover surfaces. The ridge
morphology becomes very distinct and different Side 51
Side 52
Each morphology is shown here by its preferred orientation (fig. 4). The ridges are typified by their overall longitudinal shape and parallel cluster which clearly manifest continuous, parallel, narrow and low-relief curved lineaments. Because of their gently arcuate plan-view form (fig. 6), their bearing gradually changes from Nl22°E (site A) to Nl72°E in the south (site D). Curved vegetated beach ridges are very common along spits and were studied by Reinson & Rosen (1982), Martini (1975), Swift (1968), and by Semeniuk & Johnson (1982). In southeast Australia the proposed modes of beach ridge formation were accreted bars and berms (Hine, 1979), and trapping of eolian sand within pioneer plant species, thereby composing a crest and swale topography of incipient and older foredunes (Hesp, 1984). The area to the southwest distinctly lacks this sharp linearity and parallelism, and shows instead a patchy pattern, flatter surface, and a N67°E trend which clearly differs from that of the ridges. The sandy composition, patchy form and preferred orientation suggest a fixed eolian sheet, reflecting former eastward-moving coastal dunes. The directional discordance and the morphology separate the ridges most distinctly from the eolian sheets and permit defining within the ridge area patches which have already been reworked, i.e. which have attained, through eolian activity, the directions and the characteristic eolian sheet morphology (fig. 6). Soil DevelopmentThe Atlantic climate combined with the sandy parent material and with Ericaceae and other heath vegetationcover favor podzolization on both the ridges and the eolian sheets. The typical sandy soil profile on the ridges lacks multicyclic soil development. Peat does not underlie the ridges and is encountered only between them, implying a very young post-ridge stage. Over the entire ridge area the soil profiles are concordant with the topography, i.e. no major ridge truncation has occurred since the soil was formed except recent cattle deflation. In the southwest area (fig. 4) two relatively well- developed, superimposed soil units are the rule, each followed by nondeposition and soil formation. On site F3 (fig. 4) four sequences of AO +A2 horizons were observed, indicating higher dynamics and cyclicity. The soil sequences on the eolian patchy morphology suggest several eolian import episodes. The internal structure of the ridgesInternal structures often serve as a clue to palaeogeography. Along rapidly accreting beaches, berm-ridges are the most abundant structures. Clifton (1969) showed the gentle dipping sets of parallel, tabular lamination to be characteristic of the foreshore-swash zone. Fraser and Hester (1977), Hine (1979), and Semeniuk & Johnson (1982) also observed low angle (B°-12°), seaward-dipping planar cross-stratification on tops of berms and ridges. The ridges in the study area reveal internal structures mainly in their B horizon which is neither obliterated by roots, nor by the soil-forming processes. High-angle (23°-32°) planar cross-stratification was observed, dipping toward the south at site A and site C, and eastward at site D (fig. 7). Such high inclination, up to the angle of repose, typifies eolian activity. However, swash overtopping and ridges and runnel systems may also form landward steep (20°- 25°) dips (Hine & Boothroyd, 1978). Final ridgewelding and runnel-fill may result in moderation of the dip and even in its reversal (Dabrio, 1982). Such a process seems to be demonstrated at the NE flank of the ridge exposures at site A (fig. 7). Sets of planar, low-angle lamination (2°-15°), dipping northward and southward, are the main component of the mega- tabular cross-stratification exposed in the trenches. No trough cross-bedding was encountered. The planar, low-angle, northward-dipping beds suggest beach face stratification and may reflect a swash bar, a berm or eolian windward topset laminae. The present wind regime fits the main dip directions in the ridges N32°E-N9O°E, including the northward dipping foresets at site A. The discordance of the inner ridge structure with the topography implies a modificational phase, predating final stabilization and indicating that the ridges are secondary sedimentary structures. In the swales the sand is overlain by peat which was, however, not Side 53
encountered
below the ridges and therefore does not imply Structure,
pattern and morphology suggest that the ridges in the study area are stillsand features composed of beach face sediments topped by eolian activity. However, neither the internal structure nor morphology clearly differentiates between the beach and the eolian components. Environmental
discrimination based on grain-size The hyperbolic shape triangle in fig. 8 clearly shows that none of the samples has a log-normal distribution. A few of the samples (e.g. Forest 3.2 and Forest 3.3) have a skewed log-Laplace distribution, which is very similar to the log- hyperbolic distribution (Fieller et al., 1984). The rest of the samples have a log-hyperbolic distribution. Side 54
Parameters from
this latter distribution were therefore In the bivariate plot of size versus sorting (fig. 9) all samples of each station (except F3) are well concentrated and separated from each other, i.e. size-sorting characteristics change very little at each station down through the soil profile. No clear separation between the eolian (F) samples and those of the ridges (A-D) is evident. The data suggest that in the studied coastal plain, which transformed during upper holocene from a beach to coastal dunes; environmental discrimination, basedon grain size parameters, is inconclusive. Hobday & Orme (1974) reported in a similar study that eolian sands, with steeply dipping-cross-bedding (up to 40), were almost indistinguishable from the beach washover deposits, except for some samples which were better sorted. The lack of environmental distinction within the ridges, between the lower, probably beach sands and the top units, point to the same beach-eolian resolution problem. GRAVELLY SPITSTwo raised gravelly spits were observed in the study area. Spit 1, initially observed by Jessen (1920), demonstrates on air photos (fig. 10) and in topographic maps (figs. 4, 6) a typical recurved shape, including hooks, whereas spit 2 is linear. The spits are of similar length: spit No lis 1.6 km long and spit No. 2 is 1.8 km long. Their width ranges from 100 to 300 m and both reflect a southeastward logshore drift and show a typical asymmetric cross sectional form. Gravel mining exposed a stratigraphic section at the NW flank of spit 1 where three main sedimentary units stand out: A. An upper,
open-framework cobble unit with small boulders (260-270
mm) composing the coarsest size. matrix, rich with
oyster shells. C. Pebbles and
small cobbles in a well-sorted, chert-rich granule
matrix.(xix The granulometric characteristics of spit 2 are similar. Oyster beds (Oystria Edulis) were observed at the two top gravel units of spit 1 and the top of spit 2. The Oyster beds indicate relatively high sea temperatures, high current velocities and a high degree of oxygen saturation (Steeman-Nielsen, 1938). In addition to the two spits, gravel was encountered in many localities along the southern study area below the peat and sand, probably indicating a deeper bed, which predates both spits. The overwhelmingly flat and tabular debris of chalk and chert observed along the Hjardemaal slopes suggests that the spit gravel should be traced back to the structurallycontrolled debris along the encircling Danian chalky former sea cliffs, which served as eroding headlands. Inheritance is thus suggested as the dominating shape factor. The structurally-controlled bladed form of many of the clasts contributed towards a strong preferred fabric. Pebble segregation has been suggested as a visual criteria for interpretation for the shallow marine environment (Clifton, 1973). Spit 1, however, displays some matrixsupported fabric, including muddy carbonate sand (fig. 11) with floating pebbles which suggests high-viscosity flows. The spit environment, however, lacks other diagnostic criteria of such slurry flows, i.e. poor sorting, poor roundness and a massive and chaotic structure. Infiltration of sand into the pores of gravel (Martini, 1975) would not form an unsupported framework. An initial process of clast- rounding and sorting in an open, clastsupported framework (Walker, 1975; Nemec et al., 1980) is therefore suggested, i.e. under the higher sea levels of the Littorina/Tapes stage, disturbance of the Hjardemaal slopes must have caused instability and transformed the muddy carbonate and the entrapped beach gravel into debris flows (Middleton& Hampton, 1973; Carter, 1975). Beach drifting later reshaped the sediment mass into a recurved spit in which the former flow texture is still evident. UPLIFT AND DATINGDeduced from the general regional holocene isostatic upheaval (Mertz, 1924) the study area has been raised by 4.5 m to 5 m. The spits are, however, higher: 8-9 m. Their altitude may reflect the summed heights of different factors: set-up and uprush heights (~3 m) and an unknown, possibly higher than today, tidal factor (Steeman-Nielsen, 1938), possibly salt dome tectonic upheavel, (Hansen & Håkonsson, 1979), and the postglacial isostatic rebound. This implies that only about half of the altitude of the spits should be related to isostatic rebound, corroborating the range of rebound put forward by Mertz (1924). The southernmost area in Jutland covered by glaciation is 60 km south to the study area. The moderate isostatic rebound Side 55
encountered in
the study area reflects the proximity to Table 1 summarizes the C-14 dating of the oysters and the organic soil samples within the study area. The dates of the oysters indicate the time they lived, their shells being later incorporated in the gravel, thus indicating the minimum age for the spits. Sample RT 823 A dated at 3980 ±122 YBP was taken from an open-framework gravel unit at a height of 5.2 m (DNN), and was further followed up to +8 m. The open- framework suggest a transgression phase which can be correlated with the transgression at Bjerregaard, 30 km east of the study area, dated at 3990 YBP (Petersen, 1981). The datings thus confirm that the highest marine limit in this part of the country was reached at a subboreal transgression (Petersen, 1981). The samples from the forested eolian sheet (F, F2, F3, F4) show older dates in a south-eastern direction. This might reflect a gradual weakening trend of the eolian activity, which is also shown by the relative complex soil profiles in the southern part of the study area. However, it might also indicate a coastline retreat towards the north, here recorded by successive eolian episodes. Peat formed between the ridges since 1020 AD (sample "Lowland"). As the peat does not underlie the ridges but is encountered only between them, the ridges must have predated the peat. The two samples from the "Forest" (F)site provide dates of the same trench. The 90 cm deep soil indicates a post Middle Ages eolian flux, whereas the top soil is modern and most probably reflects reworking during the 1950s when the forest was planted to prevent further eolian activities (Ranger Nord, pers.com.). The post 1950 dating of sample RT 824 A seem to indicate Side 56
cattle
deflation, frequently observed in the ridge zone.
These datings seem to corroborate the model put forward by Christiansen & Bowman (1986), that eolian activity took place around 500 AD and 1500 AD, both periods of low sea- level. During the high sea-level period around 1000 AD the low-lying areas were water logged and peat formation started. Apparently, the sixteenth century eolian flux only capped the raised beaches in the northern part of the study area and did not bury the major landscape features. Gry (1979) made similar observations to the east of the present study area. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONSThe embayment configuration of the study area during the Littorina/Tapes period and its orientation relative to the eolian and longshore-driven sands suggest that the study area operated as a shallow, semi-enclosed and bedrock-bounded low- energy embayment, at the lee of the Hanstholm and Hjardemaal headlands. The study area was a sink, which acted as a sediment trap, similar to the barrier and spit model of Hine (1979) and that of Roy & Thorn (1981). The eastward longshore sand transport caused an abundance of sediment bypassing (Petersen, 1981) with some leakage into the bay. The ridge system designates a landward sediment transgression, i.e. filling the embayment by advancing sediment masses, arrested from the general longshore drift, resulting in a stepwise shoreline propagation. The study area gradually became barred and finally land-blocked by ridges. The dying out of ridges eastwards reflects a deeper bathymmetry at the base of Hjardemaal Knude, where supposedly a deeper channel was located and no significant terrigeneous muds have been revealed. Following this model the ridges are fingerprints of pulsatory accumulative beachlines, formed by beach-swash processes and capped by a moderate dune cover. The ridges, however, may also reflect a multiple bar system, typical of small water bodies with abundant sand supply (Exon, 1975; Nillson, 1979; Short, 1975). The ridge morphology bears many characteristics of multiple longshore sand bars which are linear, symmetrical or asymmetrical, occurring in large numbers, regularly spaced, oriented parallel to the coastline, and of limited fetch and depthconditions, all of which produce a narrow-banded wave spectrum, typical of low- energy wave condition and uniform processes (Nillson, 1979). This explanation emphasizes mainly the shallow and protected submarine conditions. The data are, however, inconclusive as to which model is the true one. SammendragPå den hævede Littorina/Tapes havbund i området mellem Hansted Knuden og Hjardemål Knuden er der foretaget undersøgelser af den sen-holocene kystudvikling. Undersøgelserne har koncentreret sig om sandede strandvolde og andre rygge samt odder opbygget af materiale med grovere kornstørrelser. Den stratigrafiske og strukturelle tolkning bygger på tværprofiler gravet gennem voldene. Den morfologiske tolkning af området bygger dels på feltarbejde dels på flyfotos og kortblade. Sedimenternes kornstørrelser er blevet analyserede med henblik på differentiering mellem marin og aeolisk oprindelse. Organisk jordbundsmateriale samt marine muslingeskaller er blevet C-14 analyseret med henblik på udredelse af områdets tidsmæssige udvikling. De marint dannede volde udgør et velorganiseret mønster, hvorimod den æolisk prægede morfologi er "rodet". Der er en klar retningsmæssig diskordans mellem disse to morfologiske enheder. De højest beliggende dele af odderne, der ligger 8-9 m over DNN er dateret til 4700-4000 BP, det vil sige den sidste del af Tapes/Littorina transgressionen. Fratrukket virkningen af vindstuvning og opskyl passer disse højeste marine aflejringer ind i det generelle billede for landhævningen siden ovennævnte transgression. Dateringen af det organiske materiale, der er taget fra to ovenover hinanden liggende podzoller, antyder at området er præget af sandflugt i perioderne omkring 400-500 AD og omkring 1400-1500 AD. Det har ikke ud
fra kornstørrelsesanalyserne eller ud fra intern
Datasættet fra området antyder, at det har fungeret som en halvlukket og beskyttet bugt, der er blevet transgrederet af sedimenter fra transporten langs den jyske vestkyst. Over disse sedimenter er der en moderat æolisk akkumulation. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTThe authors are grateful to J.T. Møller for critically reviewing the manuscript and to C. Aub-Robinson for his kind and constructive comments. We sould like to thank I. Carmi and S. Kasas for C-14 measurements. ReferencesBagnold, R.A.
(1941): The physics of blown sand and desert Barndorff-Nielsen, O.
(1977): Exponentially decreasing distributions Barndorff-Nielsen, O. &Blaesild, P. (1981): Hyperbolic distributions and ramifications: contributions to theory and applications. In: Taillie, C. Patil, G.P. & Baldessari, B.A. (eds.): Statistical distributions in scientific work 4:19-44. Dordrecht: Reidel Publ. Barndorff-Nielsen, O. &
Christiansen, C. (1986): The hyperbolic Bruel, J.
(1918): Klitterne i Vestjylland og på Bornholm.
København. Carmi, L
(1987): Rehovot Radiocarbon measurements - 111.
Carmi, I.
Noter, Y. & Schlesinger, R. (1971): Radiocarbon
measurements Carter, R.M. (1975): A discussion and classification of subaqueous mass-transport with particular application of grainflow, slurry flow and fluxoturbidites. Earth Sei. Rev., 11:145-147.1:145- Christiansen,
C. & Bowman, D. (l986): Sea level changes, coastal
Clifton, H.E.
(1969): Beach lamination, nature and origin. Marine
Clifton, H.E.
(1973): Pebble segregation and bed lenticularity in
Dabrio, C.J.
(1982): Sedimentary structures generated on the
Exon, N.F.
(1975): An extensive offshore and bar field in the
Fieller,
N.R.J., Gilbertson, D.D. & Olbricht, W. (1984): A
new Floden, T.
(1973): Notes on the bedrock of the eastern Skagerrak
Fraser, G.S.
& Hester, N.C. (1977): Sediments and sedimentary
Gry, H.
(1979): Beskrivelse til Geologisk Kort over Danmark,
Hansen, E.
(ed.) (1968): Vandbygningsvæsenet 1868-1968. København.
Hansen, J.M.
&Hdkonsson, E. (1980): Thistedstrukturens geologi,
Hesp, P.A.
(1984): Fordune formation in southeast Australia. In:
Hine, A. C.
(1979): Mechanisms of berm development and resulting
Hine, A.C.
&Boothroyd, J.C. (1978): Morphology, processes and
Hobday, D.K.
& Orme, A.R. (1974): The Port Dumford Formation:
Jensen, J.L.
(1983): Maximum likelihood estimation of the hyperbolic
Jessen, A.
(1920): Stenalderhavets udbredelse i det nordlige
Jylland, Martini,
I.P.(\ 975): Sedimentology of a lacustrine barrier
system Mertz, E.L.
(1924): Oversigt over de sen- og postglaciale
niveauforandringer Middleton, G.V. & Hampton, M.A. (1973): Sediment gravity flows: Mechanics of flow and deposition. In: Middleton, G.V. & Bouma, A. H. (eds.): Turbidities and deep water sedimentation. Soc. Econ. Paleont. and Mineral., Short course lecture notes, 1-38. Nemec, W., Porebsky, S.J. & Steel, R.J. (1980): Texture and structure of resedimented conglomerates: example from Ksiaz formation (Famennian-Tournaisian) Southwestern Poland. Sedimentology, 27:519-538. Nielsen, V.H. & Pedersen, O.M. (1985): Sammenhæng mellem overfladevand og grundvand i et kalkreservoir belyst ved geofysiske metoder, Unpublished M.Se. thesis, Geol. Inst. Univ. Aarhus. Nillson, H.D.
(1979): Multiple longshore sand bars. Environment Petersen,
K.S. (1976): Om Limfjordens postglaciale marine
udvikling Petersen,
K.S. (1981): The Holocene marine transgression and its
Reinson, G.E.
& Rosen, P.S. (1982): Preservation of ice-formed
Roy, P.S.
& Thorn, B.G. (1981): Late Quaternary marine
deposition Royal
Hydrographie Office (1967): Den Danske Lods, l,
Copenhagen. Semeniuk, V.
& Johnson, D.P. (1982): Recent and Pleistocene
Short, A.D.
(1975): Multiple offshore bars and standing waves.
Steeman-Nielsen, E. (1938):
De danske farvandes hydrografi i Swift, D.
J.P. (1968): Coastal erosion and transgressive
stratigraphy. Thom, B.G.
(1983): Transgressive and regressive stratigraphies
Walker, R.G.
(1975): Generalized facies models for sedimented
|